The Death of Dutch Schultz
Still suspicious at Luciano after the Weinberg betrayal, Gangland legend has it that Schultz soon went before the Commission, a forum for leading members of organized crime, and presented a plan to kill his nemesis, U.S. Attorney Tom Dewey. While some Commission members, including
Albert Anastasia and
Jake Shapiro supported Schultz's proposal, the majority were against it, on the basis that the full weight of the authorities would come down on them if they were to hit Dewey. Schultz was furious at this outcome; he accused the Commission of trying to steal his rackets and "feed him to the law." After Schultz left the Commission decided finally eliminate him.
Murder, Inc. head
Louis Lepke, was tasked with the "hit".
At 10:15 pm on
October 23, 1935, Dutch Schultz was killed at the Palace Chophouse in
Newark, New Jersey which Schultz was using as his new headquarters.
Gangland legend has it that Schultz left the back room and went to the bathroom. Soon after
Charles "The Bug" Workman and
Emanuel "Mendy" Weiss, two
hitmen working for
Louis "Lepke" Buchalter's Murder, Inc., entered the establishment. Accounts vary of what happened next; what is known for certain is that Emmanuel Weiss carried a sawed-off
12-gauge shotgun loaded with buckshot, and Charles Workman was armed with a
.38 special revolver and a
.45 automatic.
Workman and Weiss opened fire on the three men in the back room:
Otto Berman, Schultz's chief henchman,
Abe Landau, and Schultz's bodyguard,
Bernard "Lulu" Rosencrantz.
Workman then entered the bathroom and found Schultz still at the urinal. Schultz was unarmed, except for a (3.5 inch) "
Chicago Spike"-style switchblade knife. Schultz had left his gun on the table, not expecting to need it during his visit to the toilet. Workman fired two shots from his .45. The first bullet missed Schultz entirely. However, the second bullet struck Schultz slightly below the heart, ricocheted off bone and damaged Schultz's spleen, stomach, colon, liver, and gall bladder, then tore out of his back.
Workman returned to the back room and discovered that Weiss had left the restaurant. Miraculously, both Rosencrantz and Landau were still alive; both men were following Weiss and pumping lead at him. Landau was clutching his neck to stop the spray of blood from his severed artery while still shooting. Landau fired all the bullets from his .45 without hitting Weiss. Weiss jumped into their getaway car and ordered the driver, Seymour "Piggy" Schechter, to take off, leaving his associate Workman behind. Workman ran out the front door of the Palace to find that his ride was gone, and ran off into the night. Landau had collapsed on a trash can, weak from loss of blood. Back inside, Rosencrantz, his .45 empty, finally fell face down on the floor.
Shortly after Workman fled, Schultz staggered out of the bathroom, clutching his side. According to legend, Schultz did not want to be found dead on the floor of a men's room. He therefore picked up his hat, staggered back to his seat in the backroom, sat down, and slumped over the table. Schultz called for someone to get an ambulance; Rosencrantz pulled himself to his feet and walked to the bar. He then demanded that the bartender (who had been hiding throughout this mayhem behind the register) give him change for a quarter; after all, a local call only cost a nickel in 1935! Rosencrantz went to the phone booth by the bar, deposited a nickel, and called for an ambulance. He then collapsed against the wall of the phone booth.
When the ambulances arrived, the attendants found Landau first. He was still sitting on the trash can with his arms dangling at his sides. The attendants then discovered Rosencrantz lying inside the phone booth; he was strapped to a gurney and taken away. While waiting for Schultz's ambulance to arrive, the police interrogated him and gave him a shot of
brandy. After being loaded into the ambulance, Schultz gave the attendant $720 and asked them to take good care of him.
Otto Berman was the first to die at 2:20 that morning.
At the hospital, Landau and Rosencrantz waited for surgery and refused to say anything to the police until Schultz arrived and gave them permission; even then, they provided the cops only minimal information. Abe Landau died eight hours after the shooting. Meanwhile, Rosencrantz was taken into surgery, where his injuries were so great that doctors found themselves unsure of where to start. In what can be considered a medical marvel, Lulu Rosencrantz lasted 29 hours after the shooting. He was age 33.
Before Schultz went to surgery, the gangster received the
Last Rites from a
Roman Catholic priest at his request. He wanted to die a Catholic, which was the faith of his wife. Doctors performed surgery, but they were unaware of the extent of damage done to his abdominal organs; Dutch Schultz would die of
peritonitis 22 hours after being shot.
Charles Workman was eventually convicted of Schultz's murder and served 23 years in prison. Emmanuel Weiss was executed in New York for another murder in 1944.