In early May
1593 several bills were posted about London threatening Protestant refugees from
France and the
Netherlands who had settled in the city. One of these, the "Dutch church libel", written in
blank verse, contained allusions to several of Marlowe's plays and was signed "
Tamburlaine." On
11 May the
Privy Council ordered the arrest of those responsible for the libels. The next day, Marlowe's colleague
Thomas Kyd was arrested. Kyd's lodgings were searched and a fragment of a
heretical tract was found. Kyd asserted, possibly under
torture, that it had belonged to Marlowe. Two years earlier they had both been working for an
aristocratic patron, probably
Ferdinando Stanley, Lord Strange, and Kyd suggested that at this time, when they were sharing a workroom, the document had found its way among his papers. Marlowe's arrest was ordered on
18 May. Marlowe was not in London, but was staying with Thomas Walsingham, the cousin of the late Sir
Francis Walsingham, Elizabeth's
principal secretary in the 1580s and a man deeply involved in state espionage. However, he duly appeared before the Privy Council on
20 May and was instructed to "give his daily attendance on their Lordships, until he shall be licensed to the contrary." On
30 May, Marlowe was murdered.
Various versions of Marlowe's death were current at the time.
Francis Meres says Marlowe was "stabbed to death by a bawdy serving-man, a rival of his in his lewd love" as punishment for his "epicurism and atheism". In
1917, in the
Dictionary of National Biography, Sir
Sidney Lee wrote that Marlowe was killed in a drunken fight, and this is still often stated as fact today.
The facts only came to light in
1925 when the scholar
Leslie Hotson discovered the
coroner's report on Marlowe's death in the
Public Record Office. Marlowe had spent all day in a house (
not a tavern, as is widely claimed, even in some biographies) in
Deptford, owned by the widow
Eleanor Bull, along with three men,
Ingram Frizer, Nicholas Skeres and Robert Poley. All three had been employed by the Walsinghams. Skeres and Poley had helped snare the conspirators in the
Babington plot. Frizer was a servant of Thomas Walsingham. Witnesses testified that Frizer and Marlowe had earlier argued over the bill, exchanging "divers malicious words." Later, while Frizer was sitting at a table between the other two and Marlowe was lying behind him on a couch, Marlowe snatched Frizer's dagger and began attacking him. In the ensuing struggle, according to the coroner's report, Marlowe was accidentally stabbed above the right eye, killing him instantly. The jury concluded that Frizer acted in self-defence, and within a month he was pardoned. Marlowe was buried in an unmarked grave in the churchyard of
St. Nicholas, Deptford, on
1 June1593.
Marlowe's death is alleged by some to be an assassination for the following reasons:
# The three men who were in the room with him when he died were all connected both to the state secret service and to the London underworld. Frizer and Skeres also had a long record as loan sharks and con-men, as shown by court records. Bull's house also had "links to the government's spy network."
# Their story that they were on a day's pleasure outing to
Deptford is considered implausible. In fact, they spent the whole day closeted together, deep in discussion. Also,
Robert Poley was carrying confidential despatches to the Queen, who was at her palace of Nonsuch in Surrey, but instead of delivering them, he spent the day with Marlowe and the other two.
# It seems too much of a coincidence that Marlowe's death occurred only a few days after his arrest for
heresy.
# The manner of Marlowe's arrest suggests causes more tangled than a simple charge of heresy would generally indicate. He was released in spite of
prima facie evidence, and even though the charges implicitly connected
Sir Walter Raleigh and the Earl of
Northumberland with the heresy. Thus, it seems probable that the investigation was meant primarily as a warning to the politicians in the "
School of Night," and/or that it was connected with a power struggle within the Privy Council itself.
# The various incidents that hint at a relationship with the Privy Council (see above), and by the fact that his patron was Thomas Walsingham, Sir
Francis' second cousin, who was actively involved in intelligence work.
For these reasons and others, some believe there was more to Marlowe's death than emerged at the inquest. It is also possible that he was not murdered at all, and that his death was faked. However, on the basis of our current knowledge, it is not possible to draw any firm conclusions about what happened or why. There are many different theories, of varying degrees of probability, but no solid evidence. Since there are only written documents on which to base any conclusions, and since it is probable that the most crucial information about his death was never committed to writing at all, it is unlikely that the full circumstances of Marlowe's death will ever be known.