On
September 13, the day before McKinley succumbed to his wounds, Czolgosz was transferred from the police headquarters which was undergoing repairs, to the Erie County Women's Penitentiary until the 16th, after which he was taken to the Erie County Jail before being arraigned before County Judge Emery. After the arraignment, he was transferred to
Auburn State Prison.
A
grand jury indicted Czolgosz, who spoke freely with his guards, yet refused all interaction with Robert C. Titus and Lorin L. Lewis, the prominent judge-turned-attorneys assigned to defend him, and with the expert sent to test his sanity.
The
district attorney at trial was Thomas Penny and his assistant Mr. Haller, who made a "flawless" performance. Although he answered that he was pleading "Guilty", the presiding Judge overruled and entered a "Not Guilty" plea on his behalf.
He was convicted and sentenced to death on
September 23, in a brief trial that lasted eight and a half hours from jury selection to verdict. Upon returning to Auburn Prison, he asked the Warden if this meant he would be transferred to
Sing Sing to be electrocuted, and seemed surprised to learn that Auburn had its own
electric chair.
He was executed by
electrocution, by three jolts at 1700
volts each, on
October 29, 1901, in Auburn Prison in
Auburn, New York. His brother Waldek and his brother-in-law Frank Bandowski were in attendance, though when Waldek asked the Warden for his brother's body to be taken for proper burial, he was informed that he "would never be able to take it away" and that crowds of people would mob him, so the body had to be buried on prison grounds.
His last words were "I killed the President because he was the enemy of the good people — the good working people. I am not sorry for my crime." As the prison guards strapped him into the chair, however, he did say through clenched teeth, "I am sorry I could not see my father."
Sulfuric acid and lye were thrown into his coffin so that his body would be completely disfigured, and to aid in its decomposition. His letters and clothes were burned.
Emma Goldman was arrested on suspicion of being involved in the assassination, but was released because there was no evidence to support this suspicion.
The scene of the crime, the Temple of Music, was torn down in November 1901. A stone marker in the middle of Fordham Drive, a residential street in Buffalo today marks the approximate spot where the event occurred. Czolgosz's revolver is on display at the Pan-American Exposition exhibit of the
Erie County Historical Society in
Buffalo.