Incompleteness and philosophy
Apart from his work on Ludwig Wittgenstein, Jacques Bouveresse is interested in the
incompleteness theorems of
Kurt Gödel and their philosophical consequences. It is on this account that he has attacked, in a popular work
Prodiges et vertiges de l'analogie, the use made of these theorems by
Régis Debray. Bouveresse denounces the literary distortion of a scientific concept for the purpose of a thesis. This distortion, according to him, has no other purpose than to overwhelm a readership which lacks the training necessary to comprehend such complex theorems. Bouveresse's reproach to Debray is not that he uses a scientific concept for the purpose of an analogy, but that he uses such a difficult to understand theorem in the attempt to provide an absolute justification in the form of the classic sophism of the argument from authority.
The incompleteness of a formal system which applies to
certain mathematical systems in no way implies th incompleteness of
sociology, which is not, by definition, a formal system.