Brady was selected with pick #199, a compensatory pick, of the 2000 NFL Draft. According to
Michael Holley's book
Patriot Reign, the Patriots were considering Brady and
Tim Rattay, both of whom had received positive reviews from then quarterbacks coach Dick Rehbein. The Patriots front office ultimately chose Brady — a pick that, according to a 2007 NFL Network special, was the greatest "steal" in the history of the NFL Draft. Brady worked his way from the fourth string, to serving as the backup quarterback to
Drew Bledsoe, going 1-for-3 with 6 passing yards during his rookie season. His role changed on
September 23, 2001, when the Patriots were playing against their AFC East division rivals, the
New York Jets at
Foxboro Stadium. During that game, Bledsoe suffered
internal bleeding after colliding with Jets
linebacker Mo Lewis. New England lost both the game and Bledsoe. Soon after, Brady was named the starting quarterback. In his first two games, Brady's
quarterback ratings were unspectacular, at 79.6 and 58.7 respectively, in a 44-13 victory over the
Indianapolis Colts (in the Colts' last season in the AFC East) and a 30-10 loss to the
Miami Dolphins. However, during a mid-season match-up at Indianapolis, Brady had a passer-rating of 148.3 in a 38-17 win. Brady helped bring the Patriots to an 11-5 record and into
the playoffs.
During a 2001–2002 divisional playoff game against the
Oakland Raiders (played in January 2002), Tom Brady had been ruled as having fumbled on a pass attempt, with Oakland protecting a three-point lead. Citing the controversial "
tuck rule," where a ball is ruled an incomplete pass after the quarterback starts any forward throwing motion, referee
Walt Coleman overturned the decision after reviewing the
instant replay, calling the drop an incomplete pass rather than a fumble; fellow Michigan Wolverine
Charles Woodson was the player who made the hit on Brady. Brady, who threw for 312 yards in his first NFL playoff game, led the Patriots back from a 10-point fourth quarter deficit and engineered the winning drive in overtime to beat the Raiders. Brady was injured in the
AFC Championship Game against the
Pittsburgh Steelers and was relieved by Bledsoe. The Patriots won the game and were immediately instituted by Las Vegas oddsmakers as 14-point
underdogs against the
NFC champion
St. Louis Rams in
Super Bowl XXXVI.
With less than two minutes left in the Super Bowl, and the score tied, sportscaster
John Madden said that he thought the Patriots should let the time run out on the clock and look to win the game in overtime. Instead, Brady drove the Patriots offense down the field. The Patriots won the game on an
Adam Vinatieri field goal as time expired. Brady was named
MVP of
Super Bowl XXXVI while throwing for 145 yards and 1
touchdown.