Divorce from the Duke of Argyll
Introduced into evidence in the 1963 divorce case in which the Duke of Argyll accused his wife of infidelity was a series of
Polaroid photographs of her wearing her signature three-strand pearl necklace — and only the necklace. Also included were photographs of the bepearled duchess
fellating a naked man, and though the photographs showed his genitalia and torso, they excluded his face. It was speculated that the "headless man" was
Duncan Sandys, the minister of defence, who offered to resign from the cabinet. (Duncan Sandys, later Lord Duncan-Sandys, was a son-in-law of
Winston Churchill.) This claim has been repeated since.
Also introduced to the court was a list of eighty-eight men the duke believed had enjoyed the duchess's favours; the list is said to include two government ministers and three royals. The judge commented that the duchess had indulged in "disgusting sexual activities".
Lord Denning was called upon by the government to track down the "headless man". He compared the handwriting of the five leading "suspects" (Duncan-Sandys;
Douglas Fairbanks, Jr.; John Cohane, an American businessman; Peter Combe, a former press officer at the Savoy; and Sigismund von Braun , brother of the German scientist,
Wernher von Braun) with the captions written on the photographs. It is claimed that this analysis proved that the man in question was Fairbanks, then long married to his second wife, but this was not made public.
Granting the divorce, Lord Wheatley, the presiding magistrate, said the evidence established that the Duchess of Argyll "was a completely promiscuous woman whose sexual appetite could only be satisfied with a number of men". The duchess never revealed the identity of the "headless man," and Fairbanks denied the allegation to his grave.
Long afterward, it was claimed that there were actually two "headless men" in the photographs, Fairbanks and Sandys — the latter identified on the basis of the duchess's statement that the "only Polaroid camera in the country at that time had been lent to the
Ministry of Defense". As for the Duke of Argyll, he remarried in 1963, for the fourth time, to an American, Mathilda Coster Mortimer Heller, and died of a stroke in
1973, aged 69.