Victims of other contemporary and somewhat similar attacks and/or murders have also been suggested as additions to the list. These victims are generally poorly documented. They include:
* "Fairy Fay," a nickname for an unknown murder victim reportedly found on
December 26, 1887 with "a stake thrust through her abdomen." It has been suggested that "Fairy Fay" was a creation of the press based upon confusion of the details of the murder of Emma Elizabeth Smith with a separate non-fatal attack the previous Christmas. The name of "Fairy Fay" does not appear for this alleged victim until many years after the murders, and it seems to have been taken from a verse of a popular song called
Polly Wolly Doodle that starts "Fare thee well my
fairy fay." There were no recorded murders in Whitechapel at or around Christmas 1886 or 1887, and later newspaper reports that included a Christmas 1887 killing conspicuously did not list the Smith murder. Most authors agree that "Fairy Fay" never existed.
* Annie Millwood, born c. 1850, reportedly the victim of an attack on
February 25, 1888. She was admitted to hospital with "numerous stabs in the legs and lower part of the body." She was discharged from hospital but died from apparently natural causes on
March 31, 1888.
* Ada Wilson, reportedly the victim of an attack on
March 28, 1888, resulting in two stabs in the neck. She survived the attack.
* Emma Elizabeth Smith, born c. 1843, was attacked in Osborn Street, Whitechapel
April 3, 1888, and a blunt object was inserted into her
vagina, rupturing her
perineum. She survived the attack and managed to walk back to her lodging house with the injuries. Friends took her to hospital where she told police that she was attacked by two or three men, one of whom was a teenager. She fell into a coma and died on
April 5, 1888. This was the first killing in the "Whitechapel murders" file in contemporary police files.
*
Martha Tabram (name sometimes misspelled as Tabran; used the alias Emma Turner; maiden name Martha White), born on
May 10, 1849, and killed on
August 7, 1888. She had a total of 39 stab wounds. Of the non-canonical Whitechapel murders, Tabram is named most often as another possible Ripper victim, owing to the evident lack of obvious motive, the geographical and chronological proximity to the canonical attacks, and the remarkable savagery of the attack. The main difficulty with including Tabram is that the killer used a somewhat different modus operandi (stabbing, rather than slashing the throat and then cutting), but it is now accepted that a killer's modus operandi often changes, sometimes quite dramatically. Her body was found at George Yard Buildings, George Yard, Whitechapel. This was the second victim listed in the Whitechapel murders police file. (The third through seventh cases in the file are the canonical five listed above.)
* "
The Whitehall Mystery," a term coined for the headless torso of a woman found in the basement of the new
Metropolitan Police headquarters being built in Whitehall on
October 2, 1888. An arm belonging to the body had previously been discovered floating in the
Thames near
Pimlico, and one of the legs was subsequently discovered buried near where the torso was found. The other limbs and head were never recovered and the body never identified.
* Annie Farmer, born in 1848, reportedly was the victim of an attack on
November 21, 1888. She survived with only a superficial cut on her throat, apparently caused by a blunt knife. Police suspected that the wound was self-inflicted and did not investigate the case further.
* Rose Mylett (true name probably Catherine Mylett, but was also known as Catherine Millett, Elizabeth "Drunken Lizzie" Davis, "Fair" Alice Downey or simply "Fair Clara"), born in 1862 and died on
December 20, 1888. She was reportedly strangled "by a cord drawn tightly round the neck," though some investigators believed that she had accidentally suffocated herself on the collar of her dress while in a drunken stupor. Her body was found in Clarke's Yard, High Street, Poplar. This was the eighth case listed in the Whitechapel murders file.
* Elizabeth Jackson, a prostitute whose various body parts were collected from the
River Thames between
May 31 and
June 25 1889. She was reportedly identified by scars she had had prior to her disappearance and apparent murder.
* Alice McKenzie (nicknamed "Clay Pipe" Alice and used the alias Alice Bryant), born c. 1849 and killed on
July 17, 1889. She died reportedly from the "severance of the left carotid artery" but several minor bruises and cuts were found on the body. Her body was found in Castle Alley, Whitechapel. This was the ninth crime listed in Whitechapel murders file.
* "The Pinchin Street Murder," a term coined after a torso was found in similar condition to "The Whitehall Mystery" (though the hands were not severed), on
September 10, 1889. The body was found under a railway arch in Pinchin Street, Whitechapel. Unconfirmed speculation of the time was that the body belonged to Lydia Hart, a prostitute who had disappeared. "The Whitehall Mystery" and "The Pinchin Street Murder" have often been suggested to be the works of a serial killer, for which the nicknames "Torso Killer" or "Torso Murderer" have been suggested. Whether Jack the Ripper and the "Torso Killer" were the same person or separate serial killers of uncertain connection to each other (but active in the same area) has long been debated by Ripperologists. This was the tenth of the Whitechapel murders.
* Frances Coles (also known as Frances Coleman, Frances Hawkins and nicknamed "Carrotty Nell"), born in 1865 and killed on
February 13, 1891. Minor wounds on the back of the head suggest that she was thrown violently to the ground before her throat was cut. Otherwise there were no mutilations to the body. Her body was found under a railway arch, Swallow Gardens, Whitechapel. This was the eleventh and last of the victims included in the Whitechapel murders police file, which was closed as unsolved.
*
Carrie Brown (nicknamed "Shakespeare", reportedly for quoting
William Shakespeare's sonnets), born c. 1835 and killed
April 24, 1891, in
Manhattan, New York City. She was strangled with clothing and then mutilated with a knife. Her body was found with a large tear through her groin area and superficial cuts on her legs and back. No organs were removed from the scene, though an ovary was found upon the bed. Whether it was purposely removed or unintentionally dislodged during the mutilation is unknown. At the time, the murder was compared to those in Whitechapel though
London police eventually ruled out any connection.