Total Nonstop Action Wrestling (2003-2006)
Zbyszko debuted in
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling on
January 15, 2003 and delivered a
speech in which he exhorted the roster to respect tradition. This sparked a feud with
A.J. Styles, who was not receptive to Zbyszko's requests. On
January 29, 2003 Zbyszko faced Styles in a ten minute long match with the stipulation that, should Styles be unable to pin him twice in that time, he would become Styles's
manager. Styles was only able to pin Zbyszko once, and Zbyszko managed him for a short time before
booker Vince Russo cancelled the
angle and Zbyszko left the promotion. He returned for one night on
August 6, 2003, losing to
Kid Kash following interference from
Abyss.
Zbyszko made a full-time return to TNA on
June 23, 2004, assisting
Ron Killings in his feud with
Jeff Jarrett. On
July 14, 2004, Killings, Zbyszko,
Dusty Rhodes, Konnan and
B.G. James defeated Jarrett,
Ken Shamrock and "The Elite Guard" (
Shawn Hernandez, Chad Collyer and
Onyx) in a "ten man guitar on a pole match".
Along with
Harley Race and
Terry Funk, Zbyszko was appointed to a body known as the Championship Committee. The Committee would watch matches on
TNA iMPACT!, most of which had a ten-minute time limit, and determine a winner in the eventuality of a draw. As on practise few professional wrestling matches end in a draw, the Committee was gradually phased out.
In February 2005, Zbyszko joined
Planet Jarrett, Jarrett's dominant
heel stable. He disappeared several weeks later.
On
June 19, 2005, at
TNA Slammiversary 2005, the returning Zbyszko was named
Director of Authority, replacing Dusty Rhodes. His first act as DoA was to give Jeff Jarrett's place in the
King of the Mountain match later that night to
Raven. At
TNA Sacrifice 2005 on
August 14, Zbyszko responded to Jarrett's request for a shot at the
NWA World Heavyweight Championship by informing him that he would receive a title shot if he won his tag team match that night, but would be banned from receiving a title shot for a year if he lost the match. As Jarrett's partner,
Rhino, won the match, neither stipulation was applicable.
Zbyszko remained neutral for several months, but in
October 2005 he became exasperated with Raven, who continually accused him of robbing of the NWA World Heavyweight Championship and refusing to grant him a rematch. At
TNA Genesis 2005 on
November 13, Zbyszko told Raven to resign from TNA or have his life "made hell". After Raven refused to resign, Zbyszko forced him to wrestle
P.J. Polaco. Much to Zbysko's chagrin, Raven defeated Polaco. Nevertheless, Zbyszko continued his personal crusade against Raven, and to that end booked him into a
Raven's House of Fun Match, again with an unknown opponent, for the
December 3 episode of iMPACT!. The opponent turned out to be the entire
Diamonds in the Rough stable (
Simon Diamond, Elix Skipper, and
David Young). Despite interference from
Cassidy Riley on Raven's behalf, he was pinned and lost the match.
Raven went on to defeat his former tag team partner
Chris K. at
TNA Turning Point 2005. At
TNA Final Resolution 2006 on
January 15, 2006, Raven was scheduled to face a mystery opponent, with the stipulation that he would receive a shot at the NWA World Heavyweight Championship if he was victorious, but would be fired if he was defeated. Raven lost to the returning
Sean Waltman after Zbyszko, who refereed the match after the original referee was knocked unconscious, distracted Raven so that Waltman could deliver a
X Factor and then counted to three despite Raven placing his foot on a ring rope. Following the match, Zbyszko ordered the TNA security to escort Raven from "my arena", then mocked Raven until he was confronted by
Jackie Gayda about an undisclosed issue.
At
TNA Lockdown 2006 on
April 23, 2006, the debuting
Christy Hemme handed commentator
Mike Tenay an envelope containing a message from "TNA management" stating that Zbyszko had been placed on probation due to his conduct, while Raven had been reinstated. Raven then entered the arena and approached the ring, causing Zbyszko to evade him until he was removed by security guards. At
TNA Victory Road 2006 on
July 17, 2006, Zbyszko lost to Raven in a
hair versus hair match. He would then go on to lose a match to
Eric Young at
Bound for Glory 2006 in which he was kayfabe fired.