Ring of Honor and Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
Punk joined
Ring of Honor initially as a
babyface, but was quickly
turned heel in a feud with
Raven that featured numerous variants of
no disqualification matches. At the same time Punk joined the wrestling promotion
NWA Total Nonstop Action (TNA), where he was paired with
Julio Dinero as, ironically, members of Raven's TNA
stable The Gathering.
Punk started climbing the ranks of ROH with notable achievements including coming second at the
Second Anniversary show during the tournament to crown the first
ROH Pure Champion, losing to
A.J. Styles in the finals, and winning the
ROH Tag Team Championship twice with Colt Cabana as the
Second City Saints, both times defeating the
Briscoe Brothers to win the championship. Circa October
2003 Punk was hired as the first head trainer of the
Ring of Honor wrestling school, having previously been a trainer for the Steel Domain and Primetime Wrestling.
Meanwhile in TNA on
February 25 2004 Punk had a physical scuffle with
Teddy Hart that was broken up by
Sabu outside of a restaurant shortly before a TNA show stemming from an ROH show in which Hart performed
three unplanned spots putting several other wrestlers in danger of injury. Around the same time as the scuffle Punk and Dinero stopped appearing on TNA shows leading to speculation he was fired for the incident. However, Punk has stated that the scuffle had no bearing on his TNA career and that the reason he and Dinero stopped appearing on TNA
pay per views was that TNA officials believed that he and Dinero had not gotten over as heels, having recently turned heel with Dinero by attacking Raven forming a tag team managed by
James Mitchell leading to the officials deciding to put the
angle on hold indefinitely and thus had no use for Punk or Dinero. Punk officially quit TNA in March
2004 during the
Rob Feinstein controversy after having a dispute with the TNA offices over his ability to compete in ROH following a TNA order that their contracted wrestlers were to no longer wrestle in ROH.
In ROH Punk faced off against
ROH World Champion Samoa Joe for the championship in a famous three match series. The first match, on
June 12 2004 at
World Title Classic in
Dayton, Ohio, resulted in a 60 minute time-limit draw when neither Punk nor Joe could pin or cause the other to submit in the sixty minutes. The second match between Samoa Joe and CM Punk was planned to have occurred on
December 4 2004. However, because
Steve Corino was pulled from a match with Samoa Joe by
Pro Wrestling ZERO-ONE the second match was hastily rescheduled on
October 11 2004 for
October 16 in Punk's hometown of
Chicago, Illinois. At
Joe vs. Punk II on
October 16 they wrestled to a second 60 minute draw. In addition to becoming Ring of Honor's best selling DVD at that point, the match received the first 5-star rating by
Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter for a match in North America since 1997. Joe ended the series by defeating Punk in the third and final match on
December 4 2004 at
All-Star Extravaganza 2 in which there was a no time limit stipulation.
In June 2005, Punk accepted a deal with
World Wrestling Entertainment, after a try-out match against
Val Venis on its
Sunday Night HEAT show. Even though he had accepted the deal, Punk went on to defeat
Austin Aries to win the
ROH World Championship on
June 18 2005 at
Death Before Dishonor III with the
Pepsi Plunge.
Immediately after the match Punk proceeded to
turn heel and started an angle where he threatened to bring the ROH World Championship to WWE with him. For weeks, Punk teased the ROH locker room and the ROH fans as well as mocking the championship he possessed, going so far as to sign his WWE contract on it. A notable part of this angle was
Mick Foley making several ROH appearances, attempting to convince Punk to do the right thing and defend the title on his way out.
On
August 12 2005 in
Dayton, Ohio Punk lost the ROH World Championship to
James Gibson in a four corner elimination match consisting of himself, Gibson,
Samoa Joe and
Christopher Daniels, who re-debuted after a year and half long absence. Gibson countered Punk's Pepsi Plunge with a
Super Tiger Bomb. His final scheduled match in Ring of Honor took place at
Punk: The Final Chapter on
August 13 2005 against long-time friend Colt Cabana in a
2 out of 3 falls match, which he lost. In his last match, he was visibly crying, and was showered with streamers when he posed in the middle of the ring.
Punk made a special appearance at the ROH show
Unscripted II on
February 11 2006, when the original card had to be scrapped due to
Low Ki leaving ROH the week prior along with most of the ROH roster contracted to TNA being pulled from the show due to a snowstorm that TNA officials thought might prevent performers from reaching
a pay per view scheduled the next day. In the main event, Punk teamed with
Bryan Danielson to wrestle and ultimately defeat
Jimmy Rave and Adam Pearce in a tag team match.