Wallach made his
Broadway debut in
1945 and won a
Tony Award in
1951 for his performance in the
Tennessee Williams play
The Rose Tattoo. Additional theater credits include
Mister Roberts,
The Teahouse of the August Moon,
Camino Real,
Major Barbara,
Luv, and
Staircase, co-starring
Milo O'Shea, which depicted an aging
homosexual couple in a serious way.
Wallach's film debut was in
Elia Kazan's controversial
Baby Doll and he went on to have a prolific career in films, although rarely in a starring role. Other early films include
The Misfits,
The Magnificent Seven and as Tuco (the 'Ugly') in
Sergio Leone's The Good, the Bad and the Ugly. In 2006, Wallach made a guest appearance on the
NBC show
Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, playing a former writer who was
blacklisted in the 1950s. His character was a writer on "The Philco Comedy Hour", a comedy show that aired on the fictional NBS network. This is a reference to
The Philco Television Playhouse, several episodes of which Wallach actually appeared on in 1955. Wallach earned a 2007
Emmy nomination for his work on the show.
Before accepting a role as a villain in Leone's
Once Upon a Time in the West,
Henry Fonda called Wallach and asked "What the hell does he [Leone] know about the West?" Wallach assured Fonda he would be pleasantly surprised if he accepted the role. After the film's success Fonda called Wallach back to thank him.
Wallach and Leone, though having built a good relationship during shooting
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, had a falling-out later on. Leone had asked Wallach to play a role in his upcoming film,
Duck, You Sucker, but the actor explained he had a scheduling conflict. After much pleading Wallach finally relented and turned down the other offer and waited for Leone to raise enough Hollywood money for the picture. However, the studio Leone went to had an actor,
Rod Steiger, with one more picture in his studio contract and the studio announced that Leone would have to use him if they were to put up any financing. Leone then called to apologize to Wallach, who remained dumbstruck on the other end of the line. After even refusing to give Wallach a token payment for losing out on two jobs the actor said "I'll sue you" to which Leone replied, "Get in line," and slammed down the phone. In his autobiography, Wallach relates that being the final time that the two spoke to one another.