In 1989, Kim and
Tanya Donelly (lead guitarist of
Throwing Muses) formed the next incarnation of The Breeders. Kim played rhythm guitar and sang, Tanya played lead guitar,
Josephine Wiggs played bass, and from Kentucky,
Britt Walford (credited as Shannon Doughton) from the band
Slint took care of the drums. Kelley was asked to play on the band's debut,
Pod, but she didn't manage to get time off from work.
In 1992, Kelley joined the band as third guitarist, even though she didn't really know how to play. The
Safari EP was the first recording Kelley appeared on. Tanya left The Breeders to form
Belly a little after the release of
Safari, as did Brit. Kim suggested Kelley should be the band's new drummer. After Kelley insisted on lead guitar, Kim gave her a crash course on all the songs in the band's set. Kelley picked up quickly and learned all the lead parts on
Pod and the new parts on the album they were about to record,
Last Splash. A new drummer from Dayton,
Jim MacPherson, joined them.
Last Splash was released in 1993, the band toured opening for
Nirvana and also got a slot on the
Lollapalooza tour in 1994.