Although Andrew Moray had been thwarted by the walls of Urquhart Castle, his campaign against English rule continued unabated. Throughout the summer of 1297 he continued to mount a vigorous campaign against his enemies in Moray. One of his main foes was Sir Reginald Cheyne, whose lands were wasted, goods despoiled and his castle at Duffus burned. It was subsequently reported to King Edward that Moray and "
a very large body of rogues swept through the province of Moray towards the Spey, destroying the lands of Duffus, laid waste and captured the castle." Eventually, Cheyne was taken prisoner by Moray. This campaign bore fruit as Moray drew new supporters to his banner and English-held castles across Moray and northern Scotland fell to him. Eventually, even mightly Castle Urquhart would fall to him, too.
Although Andrew Moray was conducting a spectacularly successful campaign, little of it is recorded by history. Indeed, some of his deeds were apparently co-opted by Blind Hary and attributed to William Wallace. One such event was Wallace's attack on the port of Aberdeen, in which, according to Blind Hary, he burned English ships moored in the harbour. There is no evidence that Wallace ever attacked Aberdeen, and it has been recognised that this deed should more properly attributed to Moray.
King Edward I of England, whose attention was primarily fixed on final preparations for his impending campaign in Flanders, sought to deal with the threat posed by Andrew Moray by making use of loyal Scots nobles who had recently been released from his prisons to serve in Flanders. The king, in response to Sir William fitz Warin's description of the assault on his castle, issued orders, dated 11th June, 1297, to a number of Scots lords to raise their retinues and march into the province of Moray to relieve fitz Warin and to restore royal authority in it. Among those instructed to assist fitz Warin were Henry Cheyne,
Bishop of Aberdeen, Sir Gartnait of Mar, heir to the earldom of
Mar and whose father was currently held by King Edward in the Tower of London, and
John Comyn, Earl of Buchan and Constable of Scotland, kinsman and namesake of the Lord of Badenoch, together with his brother, Alexander. The rôle of the Comyn brothers, who were kinsmen of Andrew Moray, in dealing with the rebellion was highlighted by the king: he instructed them to remain in the north-east until every aspect of it had been stamped out.
The relief column appears to have departed from the north-eastern port of
Aberdeen sometime in early July 1297. When Andrew Moray learned of its advance against him, he marched east to confront it. The two forces met on the banks of the Spey at Enzie, where the road from Aberdeen to Inverness forded the waters of the River Spey, the eastern edge of the province of Moray.
No detailed account of what happened when the two forces met survives, but it appears that what did occur essentially replayed Andrew Moray's earlier 'dance' with the Countess of Ross. An extremely ambiguous account of events subsequently sent to King Edward by Bishop Cheyne from Inverness on 25th August, relates that after some discussion, Moray and his rebel-army withdrew into "
very great stronghold of bog and wood" where
“no horseman could be of service”. This was a highly uninventive explanation when one considers the Comyn-family pacified the province of Moray in the early thirteenth-century. It appears more likely that neither side wished to fight mean that they did not consider their enemies, and they simply went their separate ways.
But if Bishop Cheyne thought he would be able to save face with this letter, he failed to reckon with
Hugh de Cressingham, who was clearly the most able and most energetic of King Edward's administrators. Cressingham, having seen this letter, wrote to the king on 5th August: “
Sire, the peace on the other side of the Scottish Sea [Firth of Forth] is still in obscurity, as it is said, as to the doings of the earls who are there.” Clearly, he did not believe that the Scots tasked with dealing with Moray had done their duty. He was especially dismissive of the account of confrontation at the Spey: “
Sir Andrew de Rait is going to you with a credence, which he has shown to me, and which is false in many points ... you will give little weight to it.” It seems clear that Cressingham had recognised the obvious double-game that many of the Scots nobles were playing.
While Andrew Moray seized control of northern Scotland and William Wallace rampaged through west-central Scotland, a rising led by Scotland's traditional leaders was also taking place in the south of the realm. Amongst its leaders were
James, the High Steward of Scotland, and
Robert Wishart, Bishop of Glasgow. Robert Bruce of Carrick, the future king, was also a participant in this rising. But in contrast with the vigour and aggression which characterised the risings of Moray and Wallace, this rising was feeble and it quickly collapsed, surrendering at
Irvine in July when an English army arrived in its vicinity
King Edward, having apparently failed to deal with Moray by force of arms, was apparently prepared to resort to some more subtle methods to neutralise him. The English king proposed to release Sir Andrew Moray from imprisonment in the Tower to serve in
Flanders, if his son was prepared to come to London to take his father's place as a hostage. A safe-conduct allowing Andrew the younger to come to England was issued under the king's seal on 28 August 1297. There is no way of knowing whether the letter and the accompanying safe-conduct ever reached Andrew Moray but, if it did, it was ignored and Sir Andrew was forced to remain in the Tower.