Early Songwriting Success
After working for a time transcribing other people's music for a small music publisher, Webb was signed to a songwriting contract with Jobete Music, the publishing arm of Motown Records. The first commercial recording of a Jimmy Webb song was "My Christmas Tree," which appeared on
Merry Christmas, the Supremes, released in 1965. The following year, Webb met singer and producer
Johnny Rivers, who signed Webb to a publishing deal and recorded Webb's "By the Time I Get to Phoenix" on his 1966 album
Changes.."
In 1967, Johnny Rivers turned to Webb for songs for a new group Rivers's was producing called the
Fifth Dimension. Webb contributed five songs to the Fifth Dimension's album
Up, Up, and Away, which he arranged and conducted, as well as played keyboards. The song "Up, Up, and Away" was released as single in May 1967, and reached the Top Ten. The group's follow-up album
The Magic Garden, also released in 1967, was again arranged and conducted by Webb and contained all Jimmy Webb songs. In Novermber 1967, a young singer
Glen Campbell released his version of "By the Time I Get to Phoenix," which reached No. 26 and became an instant pop standard.
At the 1967
Grammy Awards, "Up, Up and Away" was named Record of the Year and Song of the Year. The two Webb songs "Up, Up and Away" and "By the Time I Get to Phoenix" collected an amazing eight Grammy Awards that night. Webb's success as a new songwriter was simply unprecedented, and underscored what would become the central dilemma in his career. While his sophisticated melodies and orchestrations were embraced by mainstream audiences, his peers were embracing the sounds of the counterculture. Jimmy Webb was quickly becoming a man out sync with his times.
In 1968, Time Magazine acknowledged Webb’s range and proficiency when it referred to his astonishing string of hits, noting "Webb's gift for strong, varied rhythms, inventive structures, and rich, sometimes surprising harmonies."
In 1968, the string of successful Jimmy Webb songs continued, with The Fifth Dimension's "Paper Cup" and "Carpet Man" reaching the Top 40, Glen Campbell's "Wichita Lineman" selling over a million copies, and Johnny Maestro and the Brooklyn Bridge scoring a gold record with "The Worst That Could Happen." Webb formed his own production and publishing company that year, Canopy, and scored a hit with its first project, an unlikely album with Irish actor
Richard Harris singing all Jimmy Webb songs. One of the songs chosen was a long, complex song with multiple movements that was originally rejected by the group Association, who originally commissioned the work. Despite the song's seven minute, twenty-one second length, Webb released "MacArthur Park" as a single, and it quickly reached No. 2 on the singles chart. The album
A Tramp Shining stayed on the charts for almost a year. Webb and Harris produced a followup album
The Yard Went on Forever, which was also successful. At the 1968
Grammy Awards, Webb accepted awards for "By the Time I Get to Phoenix," "Wichita Lineman" and "MacArthur Park."
In 1969, Glen Campbell continued the streak of Jimmy Webb hits with the gold record "Galveston" and "Where's the Playground Susie," quickly becoming the finest interpreter of Jimmy Webb songs. Webb and Campbell first met during the production of a General Motors commercial. Webb showed up to the recording session with his Beatle-length hair and approached the famous conservative singer who looked up from his guitar and simply said, "Get a haircut."
That same year, two Jimmy Webb songs became hits for the second time with Isaac Hayes's soulful version of "By the Time I Get to Phoenix" and Waylon Jennings's Grammy-winning country version of "MacArthur Park." There is no better testimony to how deeply Webb's songs influenced the music industry at the time. Webb finished up the year by writing, arranging, and producing Thelma Houston's first album
Sunshower.
As the decade came to a close, so too did Jimmy Webb's string of hit singles. He began to withdraw from the formulaic process in which he worked and began to experiment. He started work on a semiautobiographical Broadway musical called
His Own Dark City, which reflected the emotional displacement he felt at the time. He also wrote music for the films
How Sweet It Is and
Tell Them Willie Boy Is Here.