Controversy and reputation
Much that was previously considered 'fact' about Richard III has been rejected by modern historians. For example, Richard was represented by Tudor writers as being physically deformed, which was regarded as evidence of an evil character. However, the withered arm, limp and crooked back of legend are nowadays believed to be fabrications, possibly originating from the questionable history by
Thomas More, which made a deep impression upon
William Shakespeare, and was long taken as the authoritative history of events.
The
Richard III Society was established in the 20th century and has gathered considerable research material about his life and reign. Its aim is summed up by its Patron, the present
Richard, Duke of Gloucester:
"… the purpose and indeed the strength of the Richard III Society derive from the belief that the truth is more powerful than lies - a faith that even after all these centuries the truth is important. It is proof of our sense of civilised values that something as esoteric and as fragile as reputation is worth campaigning for."
The American Branch of the Richard III Society carries out its own review of all the suspects in the case of Richard III, in the on-line library "Whodunit?".
The Society of Friends of King Richard III was also set up in the 20th century in order to rehabilitate Richard and to honour his memory. The society is based in the city of
York, where following his death in 1485 it was proclaimed, that "King Richard, late reigning mercifully over us, was.... piteously slain and murdered, to the great heaviness of this city".
Richard III was found not guilty in a mock trial presided over by three Justices of the United States Supreme Court in 1997. Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist and Associate Justices Ruth Bader Ginsberg and Stephen G. Breyer, in a 3-0 decision, ruled that the prosecution had not met the burden of proof that "it was more likely than not" that the Princes in the Tower had been murdered; that the bones found in 1674 in the Tower were those of the Princes; and that Richard III had ordered or was complicitous in their deaths.
Richard III appears in the 2002 List of "
100 Great Britons" (sponsored by the
BBC and voted for by the public), alongside such others as
David Beckham and
Johnny Rotten. The
BBC History Magazine lists him under "doubtful entrants, based on special interest
lobbying or
'cult' status", and comments: "On the list owing to the Ricardian lobby, but a minor monarch".
In spite of dying so young, he's often depicted as being considerably older.
Basil Rathbone and
Peter Cook were both forty-six when they played him,
Vincent Price was fifty-one, and
Ian McKellen was fifty-six.