The idea for Amos's third solo album first originated in August 1994 during a break from the tour to promote the
Under the Pink album. Amos had split from Eric Rosse both personally and professionally after a seven-year relationship, and she took a trip to
Hawaii where she studied the Hawaiian volcano goddess
Pele, the "empowering female force" behind
Boys for Pele.
The album was recorded in an Irish church, in County
Wicklow, Ireland in 1995 as well as an old
Georgian house, also in Ireland. After two albums of piano-driven pop rock music, Amos took advantage of the church recording setting to create an album ripe with
baroque influences, lending it a darker sound and style. She added
harpsichord, harmonium, and
clavichord to her keyboard repertoire, and also included such anomalies as a
gospel choir, bagpipes, church bells, and drum programming.
Boys for Pele was released in
January 1996. Substantially longer than the first two albums at around 70 minutes, it garnered mixed reviews; some critics praised its intensity and uniqueness while others bemoaned its comparative impenetrability. It was perhaps the first in a style of which Amos seems to work, as the (comparative) musical and lyrical straightforwardness of
Little Earthquakes gave way to an interest in opaque lyrics (often centered in religion and mythology) and a darker, more complex sound. The erratic lyrical content of its songs seemed indecipherable to some fans, and the instrumentation kept it away from mainstream audiences. Nevertheless,
Boys for Pele is Amos's most successful transatlantic chart release, reaching UK #2 and US #2 upon its release at the height of her fame (and as with her first four solo albums, it has been certified platinum for sales of more than a million US copies). The accompanying tour was known as the "Dew Drop Inn" tour (a reference to a lyric from "Muhammad My Friend"); as on the album, Amos performed on harpsichord and harmonium in addition to piano.
Several singles were released from the album: "Caught a Lite Sneeze" (January 1996), "Talula" (March (UK)/May (US) 1996), "Hey Jupiter" (July (UK)/August (US) 1996), and a dance club remix by
Armand Van Helden of "Professional Widow" became a massive club hit internationally, reaching #1 on the US dance charts, and #1 in the UK. The remix was included in her later anthologies
Tales of a Librarian (2003) and
A Piano: The Collection (2006).The last single from the album was "In the Springtime of His Voodoo" (September 1996).
Also in 1996, Amos began her own
vanity label called Igloo, internal to
Atlantic Records. Her first signing (which she executively produced) was the band Pet, headed by lead singer
Lisa Papineau. Their self-titled debut album included the song "Lil' Boots," which was also featured on the soundtrack for
The Crow: City of Angels. Record sales were meager and the subsidiary label was quickly folded.
Amos performed a highly publicized television concert called "
The Concert for RAINN" in early 1997. This coincided with "National RAINN Day", and during the concert all
cable and
network television stations aired Amos's
public service announcement about the organization. During this concert Amos performed her song "Muhammad My Friend" with her friend
Maynard James Keenan of the band
Tool. The concert also introduced a year long campaign in collaboration with
Calvin Klein eyewear. Proceeds were collected for RAINN. She also co-wrote/performed a song called "It Might Hurt a Bit" with singer
Michael Stipe of the band
R.E.M.. It was intended for the soundtrack to the film
Don Juan DeMarco, but was not used and has never been released.
Amos has openly discussed her experiences with
hallucinogenic drugs, particularly in relation to the
Boys for Pele album. She claims that she had "tea with
the devil" (whom she describes as a lovely woman who dresses in white and drives an ice cream truck) during one of these experiences. This led her to write the track "Father Lucifer."