Shortly after her death, a
forged letter attacking Christianity was published under her name. The pagan historian
Damascius, "anxious to exploit the scandal of Hypatia's death", laid the blame squarely on the Christians and Bishop Cyril.
In the 14th century, historian
Nicephorus Gregoras descibed
Eudokia Makrembolitissa as a "second Hypatia".
In the early 18
th-century, the
deist scholar
John Toland used her death as the basis for an anti-Catholic tract entitled "
Hypatia: Or the history of a most beautiful, most vertuous, most learned, and every way accomplish’d lady; who was torn to pieces by the clergy of Alexandria, to gratify the pride, emulation, and cruelty of their archbishop, commonly but undeservedly stil’d St. Cyril. This led to a counter-claim being published by
Thomas Lewis in 1721 entitled
The History Of Hypatia, A most Impudent School-Mistress of Alexandria
Eventually, her story began to be infused with Christian details, as her story was first substituted for the missing history of
Saint Catherine of Alexandria.
In the 19
th-century, interest in the "literary legend of Hypatia" began to peak.
Diodata Saluzzo Roero's 1827
Ipazia ovvero delle Filosofie suggested that Cyril had actually converted Hypatia to Christianity, and that she had been killed by a "treacherous" priest.
In his 1847
Hypatie and 1857
Hypatie et Cyrille, French poet
Charles-Marie-René Leconte de Lisle portrayed Hypatia as the epitome of "vulnerable truth and beauty"
Charles Kingsley's 1853 fictionalized novel
Hypatia - or New Foes with an Old Face, which portrayed the scholar as a "helpless, pretentious, and erotic heroine", recounted her conversion by a Jewish-Christian named Raphael Aben-Ezra after supposedly becoming disillusioned with Orestes.
In 1868,
Julia Margaret Cameron produced a photographic depiction of the ancient scholar
Hypatia.
The
lunar crater Hypatia was named after the philosopher, in addition to craters named for Cyril and her father Theon. Measuring 28x41 kilometres, the crater is located 4.3°S and 22.6°E of the meridian. The 180km
Rimae Hypatia, is located north of the crater, one degree south of the equater, along the
Mare Tranquillitatis.
Despite her actual background, authors Soldan and Heppe wrote a text in 1990 arguing that Hypatia may have been the first famous "
witch" punished under Christian authority.