Extreme Championship Wrestling
Tommy Dreamer joined Eastern Championship Wrestling (ECW) in
1993, just before its name change to
Extreme Championship Wrestling. His first major
gimmick in the company had him wrestling his matches in garish green
suspenders and acting as something of a "
pretty boy" — at least in relation to the rest of the ECW roster. This gimmick got him soundly
booed by crowds, even when he became the first person in wrestling history to "kick out" out of the
pin that follows the
Superfly Splash of
Jimmy "Superfly" Snuka.
After
Michael Fay was arrested in
Singapore and sentenced to a
caning, ECW head
booker Paul Heyman decided to capitalize on the publicity by holding a
Singapore Cane match between Dreamer and
The Sandman — with the loser having to take 10 lashes. After losing the match Dreamer took his lashes, then asked the Sandman for another, causing the crowd to feel sympathy for him as he took the extra, and another. This was a launching point to an
angle that ended up blurring wrestlings "
face" and "
heel" divide, as well as start a new way of
working the fans, especially the "
smarks" — fans with some amount of inside information. In a later match Dreamer (
kayfabe) accidentally blinded the Sandman, first by knocking a lit cigarette into his eye, then hitting in the other with a
Singapore cane. Immediately after, Dreamer seemed to break kayfabe and started aiding the Sandman. He professed that he "didn't mean to do it" and that it was "an accident" as other wrestlers — face and heel — swarmed out to help. The feud eventually ended with Sandman planning to announce his retirement at an ECW show, only to attack Dreamer and reveal he was never actually blind.
Though the blind Sandman
angle was his first "major"
feud in ECW, his later, years long feud against
Raven that started in April of 1995 is arguably his most memorable. The two were portrayed as childhood friends who had been competing in different ways their entire lives. Raven's entrance into ECW had him accompanied by
Beulah McGillicutty, an overweight girl from their
kayfabe childhood who had a crush on Dreamer and was now a
Penthouse Pet. Dreamer and Raven (and
Raven's Nest) feuded for two years with Dreamer never getting a win over Raven until Raven's last match in ECW, a
Loser Leaves Town match. By the end of the feud, Beulah had left Raven and was Tommy's
valet.
After Raven went to
World Championship Wrestling, Dreamer began a feud with the
World Wrestling Federation's Jerry "the King" Lawler. The feud was largely symbolic, with Dreamer representing Extreme Championship Wrestling's "new school" style of wrestling as a concept and Lawler (with
James E. Cornette) representing the World Wrestling Federation and
United States Wrestling Association's more "old school" way of doing things.
In 1998, Dreamer had a short
feud with the
Dudley Boyz (
Buh Buh Ray and
D-Von), during which they (
kayfabe) broke Beulah's neck. In 1999, on their last night in the company, they cited this incident to get Dreamer to accept a challenge for the
ECW Tag Team Championship they had won earlier in the night. He did accept, and got the title, but was paired with the unexpected partner
Raven, who slid into the ring at the last second and made the
pin. The team only lasted a short time before it dissolved, with Raven taking the title and choosing
Mike Awesome as his new partner. He also, begrudgingly, became
ECW World Heavyweight Champion in 2000 by beating
Tazz at
CyberSlam, only to lose it to
Justin Credible just one match later.
When speaking of his title reigns on
The Rise and Fall of ECW documentary produced by
WWE Home Video Dreamer is quoted as saying:
Dreamer stayed with ECW until it folded in
2001, defeating
C. W. Anderson in an
"I Quit" match at
Guilty as Charged — the final pay-per-view — and
teaming with
Danny Doring in a win over
Julio Dinero and EZ Money in the final independent ECW show.