As a
presbyter of the church at Rome under
Bishop Zephyrinus (
199-217), Hippolytus was distinguished for his learning and eloquence. It was at this time that
Origen, then a young man, heard him preach.
It was probably not long before questions of theology and church discipline brought him into direct conflict with Zephyrinus, or at any rate with his successor
Calixtus I. He accused the bishop of favouring the
Christological heresies of the
Monarchians, and, further, of subverting the discipline of the Church by his lax action in receiving back into the Church those guilty of gross offences. The result was a schism, and for perhaps over ten years Hippolytus stood at the head of a separate congregation.
Under the persecution by Emperor
Maximinus Thrax, Hippolytus and
Pontian, who was then pope, were transported in
235 to
Sardinia, where both of them died.
From the so-called
chronography of the year 354 (more precisely, the
Catalogus Liberianus, or
Liberian Catalogue) we learn that on
August 13, probably in
236, the bodies of the exiles were interred in Rome, and that of Hippolytus in the cemetery on the
Via Tiburtina; so we must suppose that before his death the schismatic was received again into the bosom of the Church, and this is confirmed by the fact that his memory was henceforth celebrated in the Church as that of a
saint and
martyr.
Pope Damasus I dedicated to him one of his famous epigrams, and
Prudentius (
Peristephano II) drew a highly colored picture of his gruesome death, the details of which are certainly purely legendary: the myth of
Hippolytus the son of
Theseus was transferred to the Christian martyr. The mythological Hippolytus, whose name means "loose horse" in Greek, had been dragged to death by wild horses; this death became the method by which the historical Hippolytus became martyred. Hippolytus thus became the
patron saint of horses. During the
Middle Ages, sick horses were brought to St. Ippolitts,
Hertfordshire, where a church was dedicated to him.
Of the historical Hippolytus little remained in the memory of later ages. Neither Eusebius nor
Jerome knew that the author so much read in the East and the Roman saint were one and the same person. Some scholars find it unlikely that they were, alleging that differing levels of development of the doctrine of the Trinity indicates differing dates of composition. The notice in the
Chronicon Paschale preserves one slight reminiscence of the historical facts, namely, that Hippolytus's
episcopal see was situated at
Portus near Rome.
In
1551 a marble statue of a seated man was found in the cemetery of the Via Tiburtina: on the sides of the seat were carved a
paschal cycle, and on the back the titles of numerous writings. It was the statue of Hippolytus, a work, at any rate, of the
3rd century; at the time of
Pius IX, it was placed in the
Lateran Museum, a record in stone of a lost tradition.
An entry in the
Liberian Catalogue of bishops of Rome for the year AD 235 records that Hippolytus the presbyter was transported as an exile to the island of Sardinia where he gained the title of martyr by dying in the mines on 13 August AD 235. The "depositio martyrum" of the
Liberian Catalogue further records that the body of Hippolytus was brought to Rome from Sardinia and interred in the Via Tiburtina.
http://www.ccel.org/ccel/wace/biodict.h.html?term=hippolytus+romanus
Prudentius, who wrote in the 5th century records (
Peristeph. 11) a different story, claiming that Hippolytus the presbyter was torn in pieces at
Ostia by wild horses. He describes the subterranean tomb of the saint and states that he saw on the spot a picture representing Hippolytus’ execution, and he confirms the martyrdom was commemorated on 13 August.