Trent Reznor is an outspoken critic of the music industry, particularly corporate influence on his artistic freedom. As a result, Nine Inch Nails has clashed with several corporations, culminating in a decision to proceed as a free agent without any recording label contracts.
* In the early 1990s, Nine Inch Nails was involved in a much-publicized feud with TVT Records, the first record label to sign the band. Reznor objected to the label's attempted interference with his intellectual property. Ultimately, they entered into a joint venture with Interscope Records in which Reznor forfeited a portion of his publishing rights to TVT Music in exchange for the freedom of having his own
Nothing Records imprint. In 2005, Reznor sued his former friend and manager
John Malm, Jr., co-founder of Nothing, for breach of contract and fiduciary duty. Their relationship was formally severed in a New York courtroom, with damages awarded to Reznor in excess of three million US dollars.
* At the behest of
Prudential Securities bankruptcy proceedings, TVT put the rights to Reznor's recordings for the label on auction in 2005. This offer included the whole TVT catalog, including
Pretty Hate Machine and a percentage of royalties from Reznor's song publishing company, Leaving Hope Music/TVT Music.
Rykodisc, who did not win the auction but were able to license the rights from Prudential, re-issued the out-of-print
Pretty Hate Machine CD on
November 22, 2005. Ryko also reissued the "Head Like a Hole" CD and a vinyl edition of
Pretty Hate Machine on
January 31, 2006. They considered releasing a deluxe edition, just as Interscope had done for
The Downward Spiral; however, Reznor declined to produce it for them without payment.
* Nine Inch Nails was scheduled to perform at the 2005
MTV Movie Awards, but dropped themselves from the show due to a disagreement with the network over the use of an unaltered image of
George W. Bush as a backdrop to the band's performance of "
The Hand that Feeds". Soon afterwards, Reznor wrote on the official NIN website: "apparently, the image of our president is as offensive to MTV as it is to me". MTV replied that they respected Reznor's point of view, but were "uncomfortable" with the performance being "built around partisan political statements". A performance by the
Foo Fighters replaced NIN's time slot on the show.
* In
2006, after being alerted by a fan website, Reznor issued a
cease and desist to
Fox News for using three songs from
The Fragile on air without permission. The songs "La Mer", "The Great Below", and "The Mark Has Been Made" appeared in an episode of
War Stories with Oliver North detailing the
battle of Iwo Jima. A post appeared on Reznor's blog, which read: "Thanks for the Fox News heads-up. A cease and desist has been issued. FUCK Fox Fucking News." Archived at
The NIN Hotline.</bgref>
* As part of the alternate reality game which accompanied the release of
Year Zero, three tracks from the album were intentionally "leaked" prior to their official release at a number of NIN concerts on
USB flash drives. The high-quality audio files quickly circulated the internet, and owners of websites hosting the files soon received cease and desist orders from the
Recording Industry Association of America, despite the fact that the viral campaign, and the use of USB drives, was sanctioned by Nine Inch Nails' record label. The source that broke the story was quoted as saying "These fucking idiots are going after a campaign that the label signed off on."
* On
May 13, 2007 Reznor made a post on his blog on the official Nine Inch Nails website condemning
Universal Music Group for their pricing and distribution plans for
Year Zero. He criticized the company's retail pricing of
Year Zero in Australia as "ABSURD", concluding that "as a reward for being a 'true fan' you get ripped off". Reznor went on to say that when "the climate grows more and more desperate for record labels, their answer to their mostly self-inflicted wounds seems to be to screw the consumer over even more." Reznor's post, specifically his criticism of the recording industry at large, elicited considerable media attention.
* On
September 16, 2007, Trent Reznor continued his attack on what he perceived as unfairly high CD prices at a concert in Australia, urging fans there to "steal" his music online instead of purchasing it legally. The text of Reznor's speech was widely reported on
Digg:
"Last time I was here, I was doing a lot of complaining about the ridiculous prices of CDs down here. And that story got picked up and got carried all around the world and now my record label all around the world hates me, because I yelled at them, I called them out for being greedy fucking assholes. I didn't get a chance to check, has the price come down at all? I see a no, a no, a no... Has anyone seen the price come down? Okay, well, you know what that means - STEAL IT. Steal away. Steal and steal and steal some more and give it to all your friends and keep on stealin'. Because one way or another these motherfuckers will get it through their head that they're ripping people off and that's not right."
*On
October 8, 2007, Trent Reznor announced with "great pleasure" that Nine Inch Nails had fulfilled its contractual commitments to the recording industry and was now free to proceed as a "totally free agent, free of any recording contract with any label".