His big break came when he was hired as a program executive at
ABC in
1976. One year later, he moved to NBC (after being hired by
Dick Ebersol to direct comedy programming). Tartikoff took over programming duties at NBC from
Fred Silverman in
1981. At the age of 30, Tartikoff became the youngest-ever president of NBC's entertainment division.
NBC was in turmoil when Tartikoff took over. A writers' strike was looming, affiliates were defecting and the network had just three
prime time shows in the Top 20:
Little House on the Prairie,
Diff'rent Strokes and
Real People). Trouble loomed elsewhere on the schedule.
Johnny Carson was reportedly in talks to move his show to ABC. The entire cast and writers of
Saturday Night Live left the show, and their replacements had plunged the show into what is still considered its worst period. Fortunately, Tartikoff's new boss was
Grant Tinker - the quality driven producer who had built
MTM Productions into a powerhouse. The two brought a string of classics to the small screen, some with the most unlikely inspiration.
Tartikoff was impressed by
Bill Cosby's stories while guest hosting the
Tonight Show, leading him to pursue Cosby's pilot for
The Cosby Show.
Once at a meeting, Tartikoff wrote down "MTV Cops" on a napkin and handed it to
Michael Mann. The result was
Miami Vice.
Johnny Carson broke the news of his retirement in February 1991 to Tartikoff at the Grille in Beverly Hills. For several days only Tartikoff and, at the time, NBC Chairman Bob Wright knew of the planned retirement.
Knight Rider was inspired by a perceived lack of leading men who could act - Tartikoff suggested a talking car could fill in the gaps in any leading man's acting abilities.
During the casting process of
Family Ties, Tartikoff was unexcited about getting
Michael J. Fox for the role of Alex P. Keaton. However, the show's producer,
Gary David Goldberg, insisted until Tartikoff relented. Tartikoff said, "Go ahead if you insist. But I'm telling you, this is not the kind of face you'll ever see on a lunch box". Some years later, after
Back to the Future, Michael J. Fox sent Tartikoff a lunch box that had Fox's picture on it with a note inside reading "To Brandon: This is for you to put your
crow in. Love and Kisses, Michael J. Fox." Tartikoff kept the lunch box in his office for the rest of his career.
Tartikoff famously wrote in his memoirs that his biggest professional regret was cancelling the show
Buffalo Bill, which he later went on to include in a fantasy "dream schedule" created for a
TV Guide article which detailed his idea of "The Greatest Network Ever" – right alongside more conventional classics like
I Love Lucy,
The Mary Tyler Moore Show, and
Cheers.