Surfer Rosa and Doolittle
Come on Pilgrim was followed by the band's first full-length album,
Surfer Rosa. The album was recorded by
Steve Albini (who was hired by Watts-Russell on the advice of a 4AD colleague), completed in a fortnight, and released in early 1988. Albini later became notable for recording
Nirvana's In Utero at the request of Kurt Cobain, who had cited
Surfer Rosa as one of his main musical influences, and particularly admired the album's natural and powerful drum sounds — a result of Albini's influence on the record.
Surfer Rosa gained the Pixies acclaim throughout the musical world; both
Melody Maker and
Sounds gave
Surfer Rosa their "Album of the Year" award. The success of
Surfer Rosa would lead to the band signing an American distribution deal with major record label
Elektra before the release of their next album.
As with
Come on Pilgrim, the band delivered a wide range of song styles. However, sonically and thematically,
Surfer Rosa was similar to
Come on Pilgrim — from the drum-driven "Bone Machine", that showed a trademark propensity for surreal lyrics, to pop guitar songs such as "Broken Face", "Break My Body", and "Brick is Red". The band included heavier material, such as "Something Against You", with Black Francis' distorted screaming a prominent feature in the song, and
Q Magazine later named
Surfer Rosa as one of the
50 Heaviest Albums of All Time. A re-recorded version of "Vamos" — a song that appeared on
Come on Pilgrim — appears on the album. The track, "You Fuckin' Die! (I Said)" (referred to as "Bonus Track" or "Untitled" on most versions of the CD) that appears toward the end of the album is actually an accidental studio recording of Francis and Deal talking amicably and joking, and despite the title of the song, there is none of the tension present between the two that would later drive the band apart.
Surfer Rosa featured popular songs such as "
Gigantic" — their first single release and one of the few songs on which bassist Kim Deal sang lead vocals – "River Euphrates", and "
Where Is My Mind?" (), whose most famous performance was at the end of the film
Fight Club, and, as a result is one of their best-known songs to date.
After their critically acclaimed album, the band arrived in
England to support Throwing Muses on the European "Sex and Death" tour — beginning at the
Mean Fiddler in
London. The tour also took them to
the Netherlands, where the Pixies had already received enough media attention to be headlining the tour. Francis later recalled: "The first place I made it with the Pixies was in
Holland." The setlist included new songs such as "In Heaven", "Hey", and "Wild Honey Pie", and the tour became notable for the band's
in-jokes, such as playing their entire
set list in alphabetical order. The aforementioned songs were recorded in a
Peel session in July at the BBC and they soon made a second trip to the studios; choosing "Dead", "Tame", "There Goes My Gun", and "Manta Ray" to be recorded. In total, the band recorded six Peel sessions and released an album,
Pixies at the BBC, with selected recorded tracks from those sessions. Note the webpage was written before the release of
Pixies at the BBC.</bgref>
Around this time, the Pixies struck up a relationship with the British producer,
Gil Norton. Norton was to produce their second full album,
Doolittle (provisionally titled
Whore), which was recorded in the last six weeks of 1988 and seen as a departure from the raw sound of
Come on Pilgrim and
Surfer Rosa.
Doolittle had a much cleaner sound, largely due to Norton and the production budget of
US$40,000, which was quadruple that of
Surfer Rosa. Much of the album's subject matter remained similar to the previous two albums; several song titles seemed to evoke images of bloodshed and mutilation, such as "I Bleed", "Wave of Mutilation", and "Gouge Away".
Doolittle began with "
Debaser" (), an ode to the 1929
surrealist Luis Buñuel and
Salvador Dalí film
Un chien andalou. "Debaser" is perhaps their most highly regarded song; in March 2005,
Q magazine placed the song at number 21 in its list of the
100 Greatest Guitar Tracks.
Doolittle featured the prominent single "
Here Comes Your Man"; an unusually jaunty and poppy song for the band. It nearly landed the band a mimed appearance on the TV
chat show Wogan, which was mocked in the video to the song. "
Monkey Gone to Heaven", the only Pixies song with a string section, was a Top 10
modern rock radio hit in the US, reached the Top 100 in the UK and still receives regular radio play. Deal's only songwriting contribution to the album was the song "Silver" (co-written with Francis), on which Deal played
slide guitar and Lovering played the
bass guitar. Lovering sang lead vocals on "La La Love You", an atypical love song from the band.
Like
Surfer Rosa,
Doolittle was critically acclaimed by fans and
music critics alike, and it is perhaps their best-selling record; it was
certified gold by the
RIAA on November 10, 1995. It also placed on Q Magazine's 100 Greatest Albums Ever.