Pye was born in
London, the son of Henry Pye of
Faringdon House in
Berkshire (now
Oxfordshire) and his wife, Mary James, and was educated at
Magdalen College, Oxford. His father died in
1766, leaving him a legacy of debt amounting to ₤50,000, and the burning of the family home further increased his difficulties.
In 1784 he was elected
Member of Parliament for Berkshire. He was obliged to sell the paternal estate, and, retiring from
Parliament in
1790, became a police magistrate for
Westminster. Although he had no command of language and was destitute of poetic feeling, his ambition was to obtain recognition as a poet, and he published many volumes of verse.
Of all he wrote his prose
Summary of the Duties of a Justice of the Peace out of Sessions (
1808) is most worthy of record. He was made poet laureate in
1790, perhaps as a reward for his faithful support of
William Pitt the Younger in the
House of Commons. The appointment was looked on as ridiculous, and his birthday
odes were a continual source of contempt. The 20th century
British historian
Lord Blake called Pye "the worst Poet Laureate in English history with the possible exception of
Alfred Austin."
As a prose writer, Pye was far from contemptible. He had a fancy for commentaries and summaries. His "
Commentary on Shakespeare’s commentators", and that appended to his translation of the
Poetics, contain some noteworthy matter. A man, who, born in 1745, could write “Sir Charles Grandison is a much more unnatural character than
Caliban,” may have been a poetaster but was certainly not a fool.
Indeed, Pye's successor, Robert Southey, wrote in 1814: "I have been rhyming as doggedly and dully as if my name had been Henry James Pye." Unfortunately, Pye's legacy is remembered as one of the unfortunate few who have been classified as a "poetaster." He died at Pinner, Middlesex on August 11, 1813.
Pye married and had two daughters.