J. C. Bach and the symphony
The
symphonies in the Work List for J. C. Bach in the
New Grove Bach Family listed ninety-one works. A little more than half of these, 48 works, are considered authentic, while the remaining 43 are doubtful.
By comparison, the composer sometimes called "the Father of the Symphony,"
Joseph Haydn, wrote slightly over 100 symphonies. Most of these are not fully comparable to Johann Christian Bach's symphonies, because many of Johann Christian's works in this category are closer to the Italian
sinfonia than to the late classical symphony in its most fully developed state as found in the later works in this category by Haydn and Mozart.
Using comparative duration as a rough means of comparison, consider that a standard recording of one of Bach's finest symphonies, Op. 6 no. 6 in g minor, has a total time of 13 minutes and 7 seconds (as performed by
Hanover Band directed by
Anthony Halstead), while Haydn's
"Surprise" Symphony in a typical recording (by
Ádám Fischer conducting the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra) lasts 23 minutes and 43 seconds.
It is clear that the listener of J. C. Bach's symphonies should come to these works with different expectations from the ones he or she brings to those of Haydn or Mozart. Concert halls today are frequently filled with the music of Haydn, and comparatively rarely with that of J. C. Bach, which probably has less to do with their relative quality (since the music of the latter is clearly accomplished and worthy of being heard) than with their relative historical positions regarding the classical symphony. But J. C. Bach's music is more and more being recognized for its high quality and significance. The Halstead recording mentioned above is part of a complete survey of this composer's orchestral works on 22
CDs for the record label CPO, and the complete works of J. C. Bach have now been published in
The Collected Works of Johann Christian Bach.