![]() |
Sergei Taneyev |
[edit]

![]() |
Sergei Taneyev |
I think he was unnerved by the overt frankness with which Taneyev reacted to Tchaikovsky's works: Taneyev believed that one must indicate precisely what one finds to be 'faults,' while strong points would make themselves evident. He was hardly fully justified in his conviction: composers are a nervous lot and they are often particularly dissatisfied with themselves. Tchaikovsky was just such a person: he worried himself almost sick over each work and often tried even to destroy them ...Sabaneyev recalled when Tchaikovsky came to Taneyev with the Fifth Symphony. Taneyev started played through part of the manuscript at the piano. "With characteristic pedantry Taneyev began showing Tchaikovsky what he considered to be faults, thereby sending Tchaikovsky into even greater despair. Tchaikovsky grabbed the music and wrote across the page with a red pencil: 'Awful muck.' Still not satisfied with this punishment, he tore the sheet of music in half and threw it on the floor. Then he ran out of the room. Despondently Taneyev picked up the music and told me: 'Pyotr Ilyich takes everything to heart. After all, he himself asked me to give my opinion...."
"At the rehearsal of the concert he publicly declared to Balakirev: 'Mili Alekseyevich! We are dissatisfied with you.' I picture to myself Balakirev constrained to swallow a rebuke of this sort. Honest, upright and straightforward, Taneiev always spoke sharply anf frankly. On the other hand, Balakirev, of course, could never forgive Taneiev his harshness and frankness with regard to his own person."
I spend a great deal of time on preparatory work, and less time on final composition. Some items I have not finished within the last few years. Important themes which are repeated in the opera, are used by me objectively, without any reference to a particular situation, for studies in counterpoint. Gradually, from this chaos of thoughts and sketches something orderly and definite begins to emerge. Everything extraneous is discarded. That which is unquestionably suitable remains.
Before setting out for the real expounding of a composition, Taneyev used to precede it with a multitude of sketches and studies: he used to write fugues, canons, and various contrapuntal interlacings on the individual themes, phrases, and motives of the coming composition; and only after gaining thorough experience in its component parts did he take up the general plan of the composition and the carrying out of this plan, knowing by that time, as he did, and perfectly, the nature of the material he had at his disposal and the possibilities of building with that material.
This biography says:
That biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
That biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
That biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
That biography says:
This biography says:
This biography says:
That biography says:
This biography says: