Principal contralto and untimely death
She returned to the company in 1914, replacing Louie Rene as principal contralto.
Derek Oldham later reported that, in 1920, at the instance of musical director
Geoffrey Toye, Rupert D'Oyly Carte considered expanding the company's repertoire so she could play Carmen. For more than 16 years after her return, Lewis portrayed all the leading contralto roles in the company's repertory: Lady Sangazure in
The Sorcerer, Buttercup, Ruth, Lady Jane, Fairy Queen, Lady Blanche, Katisha, Dame Hannah in
Ruddigore, Dame Carruthers, and the Duchess of Plaza-Toro.
Lewis died at the age of 43 after sustaining fatal injuries in a car accident. She was travelling from Manchester to Cambridge in a car driven by
Henry Lytton in a rainstorm. Lytton was injured in the accident but recovered and returned to performing after a few months. Lewis was in the hospital for five days before succumbing to her injuries.
Queen Mary made personal enquiries, and the newspapers and the
BBC gave daily news reports about her condition.
Lewis is often cited as the greatest contralto in the history of the D'Oyly Carte Opera Company. Her powerful voice (preserved on recordings), crisp diction and formidable stage personality were well documented. She was married to the singer Herbert Heyner. Of her performance in the refurbished production of
The Mikado in 1926,
The Times wrote that she "was majestic as Katisha. ...getting a serious dramatic significance into her part and illustrating the fact that the humour of Gilbert and Sullivan comes out best by serious treatment."