Heatter remained with Mutual until, like many of the Depression and wartime broadcasters and commentators, his influence gave way to a newer generation of broadcasters, mostly those who could and did either make a transition to television or went right to the new medium and bypassed radio entirely. By the 1960s, Heatter was all but retired.
Not until the 1960 publication of
There's Good News Tonight did those who waited hungrily for his nightly news for so many years get a chance to understand what Heatter had to overcome just about every day of his life to make it on the air. But according to Irving Fang, author of
Those Radio Commentators, "That turmoil seemed to subside as the years passed by. Age gave this gentle, decent man a kind of serenity."
After his wife's death, Heatter in retirement lived with his daughter until he died of pneumonia in 1972. The audiences who were comforted by his melodious voice and his ability to find the best in even the worst news must have felt that it hurt to lose a cherished friend, but that it was a comfort to believe, in turn, that Heatter had gone to a gentler place. Where he, for a change, would be the comforted.
His daughter Maida Heatter has had a successful career as an author of cookbooks. His son
Merrill Heatter was a television writer and producer (
Heatter-Quigley Productions).