Success from 1938 to 1942
Discouraged, Miller returned to
New York. He realized that he needed to develop a unique sound, and decided to make the
clarinet play a melodic line with a
tenor saxophone on the same note, with three other saxophones harmonized within a single octave. With this new sound combination, the Miller band found success. Miller was not the first to try this style, but he was the most successful at refining it and making it key to almost his entire repertoire. After a shaky start, it made his new band a nationwide hit.
Tex Beneke, Al Klink,
Chummy MacGregor,
Billy May, Johnny Best,
Maurice Purtill,
Wilbur Schwartz,
Clyde Hurley, Ernie Caceres,
Ray Anthony, Hal McIntyre, and
Bobby Hackett were some of the musicians in the band.
Ray Eberle,
Marion Hutton, Skip Nelson,
Paula Kelly, Dorothy Claire, and
The Modernaires were the seven singers.
In September 1938, the Miller band began making recordings for the
RCA Victor Bluebird Records subsidiary. In the spring of 1939, the band's fortunes improved with a date at the Meadowbrook Ballroom in
Cedar Grove, New Jersey, and more dramatically at the Glen Island Casino in
New Rochelle, New York. With the Glen Island date, the band began a huge rise in popularity. In 1939,
Time magazine noted: "Of the twelve to 24 discs in each of today's 300,000 U.S. jukeboxes, from two to six are usually Glenn Miller's."
There were record-breaking recordings such as "Tuxedo Junction", which sold 115,000 copies in the first week. 1939's huge success culminated with the Miller band in concert at
Carnegie Hall on
October 6, with Paul Whiteman, Benny Goodman, and Fred Waring also the main attractions.
From 1939 to 1942, Miller's band was featured three times a week during a broadcast for
Chesterfield cigarettes. On
February 10 1942, RCA Victor presented Miller with the first
gold record for "
Chattanooga Choo-Choo". In 2004, Glenn Miller orchestra bassist Herman "Trigger" Alpert explanied the band's success: "Miller had America's music pulse, he knew what would please the listeners."
Although Miller had massive popularity, many jazz critics of the time had their misgivings, believing that the band's endless rehearsals and "letter-perfect playing" diminished excitement and feeling from performances. They also felt that Miller's brand of swing shifted popular music away from the "hot" jazz bands of Benny Goodman and
Count Basie towards commercial novelty instrumentals and vocal numbers. Miller was often criticized for being too commercial. His answer to the criticism was, "I don't want a jazz band". Many modern jazz critics still harbor similar antipathy toward Miller. Miller himself emphasized orchestrated arrangements over improvisation, but he did leave a little room for his musicians to ad lib. This would be best exemplified by Tex Beneke, who soloed often on songs like "Sunrise Serenade," and "Falling Leaves". In an article written by Gary Giddins for
The New Yorker in 2004, Giddins felt that these early critics erred in denigrating Glenn Miller's music, and that the popular opinion of the time should hold greater sway. The article states: "Miller exuded little warmth on or off the bandstand, but once the band struck up its theme, audiences were done for: throats clutched, eyes softened. Can any other record match "Moonlight Serenade" for its ability to induce a Pavlovian slaver in so many for so long?"
Miller and his band appeared in two
Hollywood films,
1941's,
Sun Valley Serenade and
1942's Orchestra Wives, the latter featuring future television legend
Jackie Gleason playing a part as the group's bassist. A stickler for the truth, Miller insisted on a thoroughly believable script before he'd go before
Twentieth-Century Fox cameras. Miller also demanded that the band become an integral part of the story and not just be thrown into some inconsequential scene. He had achieved star status and he was now demanding and getting star treatment.