Will's detractors point to what they call a troubling pattern of ethical lapses. Will helped
Ronald Reagan prepare for his
1980 debate against
Jimmy Carter, breaking with the journalistic tradition of neutrality. Immediately after the debate, Will—who was not a member of the
ABC News staff—appeared on ABC's
Nightline. He was introduced by host
Ted Koppel, who said "It's my understanding that you met for some time yesterday with Governor Reagan," and that Will "never made any secret of his affection" for the Republican candidate. It was not explicitly disclosed that Will had assisted with or been present during Reagan's debate preparation. Will went on to praise Reagan, saying his "game plan worked well. I don't think he was very surprised" (
Nightline Special Edition,
October 28, 1980).
Twenty-four years later, appearing on an
NPR program, Carter stated that before the 1980 debate, Will gave the Reagan campaign a top-secret briefing book stolen from Carter's office (
Fresh Air,
October 21, 2004). According to a report, he repeated this accusation in 2005 (
The Alabama Plainsman,
July 28, 2005). In a 2005 syndicated column, Will called his role in Reagan's debate preparation "inappropriate" but denied any role in stealing the briefing book. As he had done to Carter privately, Will wrote in his column that he gave the book a "cursory glance" and found it a "crashing bore and next to useless—for [Carter], or for anyone else" (
Washington Post,
August 11, 2005). In response to the column, Carter wrote a letter to the
Washington Post retracting his accusations. Carter apologized to Will for "any incorrect statement that I have ever made about his role in the use of my briefing book ... I have never thought Mr. Will took my book" (
Washington Post,
August 31, 2005).
A left-of-centre media watchdog group,
Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting, criticized Will in connection with the
1996 election, for "commenting on the presidential race while his second wife, Mari Maseng Will, was a senior staffer for the
Dole presidential campaign," including commenting on a Dole speech without disclosing that his wife had helped write it. However, Will mentioned his wife connection to the Dole campaign almost weekly on
This Week. Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting also criticized Will's dealings with Canadian-born British financier
Lord Black. Will served on an informal board of advisors to
Hollinger International, a newspaper company controlled by Black. The board met once a year and Will received an annual payment of $25,000. The board was disbanded in 2001. In March, 2003, Will wrote a syndicated column which praised a speech by Black and did not disclose their previous business relationship.