Thomas Reid's Theory of Common Sense
His theory of knowledge had a strong influence on his theory of morals. He thought
epistemology was an introductory part to practical ethics: When we are confirmed in our common beliefs by philosophy, all we have to do is to act according to them, because we know what is right. His moral philosophy is reminiscent of the Latin
stoicism mediated by the
scholastics, St. Thomas Aquinas and the Christian way of life. He often quotes
Cicero, from whom he adopted the term "sensus communis."
He set down six axioms which he regarded as an essential basis for reasoning, all derived from "sensus communis":
*That the thoughts of which I am conscious are thoughts of a being which I call myself, my mind, my person;
*That those things did really happen that I distinctly remember;
*That we have some degree of power over our actions, and the determination of our will;
*That there is life and intelligence in our fellow men with whom we converse;
*That there is a certain regard due to human testimony in matters of fact, and even to human authority in matters of opinion;
*That, in the phenomena of nature, what is to be, will probably be like what has been in similar circumstances.
These axioms did not so much answer the testing problems set by
David Hume and, earlier,
René Descartes, as simply deny them. Contemporary philosopher Roy Sorensen writes "Reid's common sense looks like an impression left by Hume; concave where Hume is convex, convex where Hume is concave. One explanation is that common sense is reactive... Without a provocateur, common sense is faceless."
His reputation waned after attacks on the
Scottish School of Common Sense by
Immanuel Kant and
John Stuart Mill, but his was the philosophy taught in the colleges of North America, during the
19th century, and was championed by
Victor Cousin, a French philosopher. Justus Buchler showed that Reid was an important influence on the American philosopher
C.S. Peirce, who shared Reid's concern to revalue common sense and whose work links Reid to
pragmatism. To Peirce, the closest we can get to truth in this world is a consensus of millions that something is so. Common sense is socially constructed truth, open to verification much like scientific method, and constantly evolving as evidence, perception, and practice warrant. Reid's reputation has revived in the wake of the advocacy of common sense as a philosophical method or criterion by
G. E. Moore early in the 20th century, and more recently due to the attention given to Reid by contemporary philosophers, in particular those seeking to defend
Christianity from philosophical attacks, such as
William Alston and
Alvin Plantinga.
He wrote a number of important philosophical works, including
Inquiry into the Human Mind on the Principles of Common Sense (1764, Glasgow & London),
Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man (1785) and
Essays on the Active Powers of Man (1788). In
1844, Schopenhauer praised Reid for explaining that the perception of external objects does not result from the raw data that is received through the five senses: