After graduation, he was cast in the television drama
Toughlove alongside
Bruce Dern, Piper Laurie, Dedee Pfeiffer (sister of
Michelle Pfeiffer), Eric Schiff and the late
Lee Remick. (This movie, in which Patric and Pfeiffer both portray alienated teenage drug addicts, has been compared by some to a suburban update of
Hud (film)...one in which Pfeiffer and Patric share the
Paul Newman role, Dern and Laurie share
Melvyn Douglas's, Remick has
Patricia Neal's and Schiff is in
Brandon De Wilde's.) The following year, Patric was cast in
Brooksfilms's sci-fi flop
Solarbabies alongside
Peter DeLuise, Jami Gertz, Lukas Haas, James LeGros (film debut),
Adrian Pasdar (film debut),
Sarah Douglas and the late
Richard Jordan.
Within a few years, Patric would reunite with Dern and Gertz for
After Dark, My Sweet and
The Lost Boys, respectively. All of his scenes in
Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line were cut before the film's release. He also appeared in the
Alec Baldwin film
The Devil and Daniel Webster, which was shot in 2001, and released in late 2007 under the title
Shortcut to Happiness. He turned down the lead role in
The Firm (1993), and the part went instead to
Tom Cruise; he also turned down the role of
Jesus Christ in
Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ (2004), which went to
Jim Caviezel. He earned rave reviews for his performance as an undercover narcotics officer in 2002's
Narc.
In 2005, Patric appeared on
Broadway as "Brick", in a revival of the
Tennessee Williams Pulitzer Prize-winning play
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof opposite
Ashley Judd, Ned Beatty and
Margo Martindale. Both he and Judd received lukewarm reviews, while stage veterans Beatty and Martindale received much acclaim and, in Martindale's case, a
Tony Award nomination.