Struggle for success (1986–1991)
After releasing five albums in five years, each accompanied by heavy media promotion and lengthy concert tours, the band lost two of its core members to fatigue and tension in
1986. After
Live Aid and
Arcadia, drummer Roger Taylor retired to the English countryside, suffering from exhaustion. This was originally announced as a one year
sabbatical, but it soon became clear that he would not be returning to the band. An official press release was issued in
April 1986 confirming his departure. Guitarist Andy Taylor, on the other hand, led the remaining members to believe he would return to work on a new Duran Duran album even as he was signing a solo recording contract in
Los Angeles. The band resorted to legal measures to get him into the studio, but after numerous delays, they let him go at last. He played on only a few songs on the next album while the disagreements were being settled.
Without a guitarist or a drummer, the three remaining members, Le Bon, Rhodes, and John Taylor had producer (and former Chic guitarist)
Nile Rodgers play a few tracks on guitar, and hired
studio musicians to play drums while they searched for replacements. Finally in
September 1986,
Warren Cuccurullo (formerly of
Missing Persons and
Frank Zappa's touring band) was hired as a sessions guitarist. With Le Bon, Rhodes, and Taylor, he recorded the rest of the
Notorious album, which was released in
October 1986. The black-and-white documentary film
Three To Get Ready chronicled the recording of the album, legal tensions, and preparations for the tour.
Although the song "
Notorious" went to number two in the U.S. and album sales were strong, the band found they had lost much of the momentum and hysteria they had left behind in 1985. In the three years between the release of
Seven and the Ragged Tiger and
Notorious, many of their teenage fans had grown up, and the music was funkier, more mature, and less "pop", given the added experience of their work on Arcadia and Power Station and with many gifted musicians. "
Skin Trade" and "
Meet El Presidente", the two subsequent singles, made the charts but fared poorly compared to the band's earlier successes.
Subsequently, Duran Duran's fame began to wane as they struggled to escape the
teen idol image and gain critical success with more complex music.
Rolling Stone said, "In their search for musical maturity, the surviving Durans have lost a good deal of their identity." Another factor was the band's dismissal of early managers the Berrow brothers. There was no announcement of the reasons for the decision, but disagreements over money, and the brothers’ involvement in Le Bon's yachting adventures (they were co-owners of
Drum) were thought to have played a part. Whatever the reason, Duran Duran switched managers frequently and undertook periods of self-management in the later stages of their career. In addition, EMI (which fired its president and went through a major corporate restructuring that summer) seemed to have lost interest in promoting the band.
The next album
Big Thing (1988) yielded the singles "
I Don't Want Your Love"(#4 at US HOT100), "
Do You Believe In Shame?" and "
All She Wants Is" (the last a top ten hit in the UK). The record was experimental, mixing influences from
house music and
rave music with Duran's atmospheric
synth pop and Cuccurullo's creative guitar work, as well as more mature lyrics (the juvenile title track notwithstanding). By the next year, after touring for the album finished, the band regained a five-man membership as Cuccurullo and tour drummer
Sterling Campbell were made full members of Duran Duran.
Inexplicably during this time, the group was credited as Duranduran on some of the releases (one word, instead of two).
The compilation album
Decade: Greatest Hits was released late in
1989, along with the
megamix single "
Burning The Ground", which consisted of woven snippets of the band's hits from the previous ten years. The single came and went with little fanfare, but the album became another major seller for the band.
However, the tepid 1990 release
Liberty (a retreat from the experimentation of
Big Thing) failed to capitalise on any regained momentum, a pattern the band repeated often in their later years. The album entered the UK album chart in the top ten, but faded away quickly. The singles "
Violence of Summer (Love's Taking Over)" and "
Serious" were only mildly successful, and the album's soft rock did not fare well against contemporaries like
Alice in Chains and
Jane's Addiction, while
Nirvana,
Pearl Jam and the
grunge revolution were just around the corner. For the first time, Duran Duran did not tour in support of an album, performing on only a handful of club dates and TV shows.
Sterling Campbell left the band early in
1991, going on to work with
Soul Asylum and
David Bowie. The quartet of Le Bon, Rhodes, Taylor, and Cuccurullo would remain intact for six more years. In
December 1991, Taylor (then 31) married 19-year-old model/actress
Amanda De Cadenet, and she gave birth to his daughter in
March 1992.