In 1980, Redford's first outing as a
director,
Ordinary People, a drama about the slow disintegration of an upper-middle class family, won him an
Oscar. Redford managed to get a powerful dramatic performance out of America's Sweetheart,
Mary Tyler Moore, as well as superb work from
Donald Sutherland and
Timothy Hutton. He also starred in
The Natural (1984), based on characters and situations from
Bernard Malamud's 1952 novel by the same name,
The Natural. The film won Redford new fans and further acclaim.
His second stint behind the camera would not be for another eight years with
The Milagro Beanfield War (1988), a well-crafted—though not commercially successful screen version of
John Nichols' acclaimed novel of the Southwest. Other directorial projects have included the successful period family drama
A River Runs Through It (1992), based on
Norman Maclean's novella, and the intelligent expose
Quiz Show (1994), about the quiz show scandal of the late 1950’s. Working from a screenplay by
Paul Attanasio with noted cinematographer
Michael Ballhaus and a strong cast that featured
John Turturro,
Rob Morrow and
Ralph Fiennes. Redford's skill behind the camera earned him well-deserved praise. Redford handpicked Morrow for his part in the film (his only high profile feature film role to date), because he liked his work on
Northern Exposure.
Besides his directing and producing duties, Redford continued acting as he entered middle age. He made a fine romantic lead opposite
Meryl Streep in Sydney Pollack's Oscar-winning
Out of Africa (1985). Although many critics complained that his portrayal of
Isak Dinesen's lover was unrealistic, Redford's characterization was more substantial than the ghostly figure of Dinesen's book. After the box-office disaster of
Havana (1990), he turned in amiable performances in the high-tech caper
Sneakers (1992), the sexy drama
Indecent Proposal (1993), with
Demi Moore, and opposite
Michelle Pfeiffer in the newsroom romance
Up Close & Personal (1996). Continuing in the romantic vein, Redford directed and starred opposite Kristin Scott Thomas in a strong adaptation of Nicholas Evans' novel
The Horse Whisperer (1998). Like his other directorial efforts, the film featured a strong cast in a drama that centered around a troubled family. His follow-up behind the camera,
The Legend of Bagger Vance (2000), portrayed star Will Smith as a black caddy with mystical powers. Redford next returned to acting playing an aging
CIA operative whose protégé goes rogue and is imprisoned in China in
Spy Game (2001).