After a rest, Garner returned to his most popular TV role in 1981 in the revival series
Bret Maverick, but NBC unexpectedly canceled the show after only one season despite reasonably good ratings. Critics noted that most of the scripts did not measure up to the first series, though Garner's performance as a 53-year-old Bret Maverick was almost universally applauded.
Jack Kelly (Bart Maverick) was slated to become a series regular had the series been picked up for another season, and he appeared in the last scene of the final episode in a surprise guest role.
During the
1980s, Garner played dramatic roles in a number of TV movies, from
Heartsounds (with
Mary Tyler Moore) to
Promise (starring
Piper Laurie) and
My Name is Bill W.. He was nominated for his first
Oscar award for
Best Actor in a Leading Role in the movie
Murphy's Romance, opposite
Sally Field. Field had to fight the studio to have Garner cast, since he was regarded as a TV actor by then despite having co-starred in the box office hit
Victor/Victoria opposite
Julie Andrews three years earlier. Apparently the fight was worth it, as in A&E's biography of Garner, Field reported that her on-screen kiss with Garner was the best cinematic kiss she had ever experienced. In 1988, Garner underwent quintuple
heart bypass surgery. Though he rapidly recovered, the doctors insisted that he stop smoking. In 1993, he played the lead in another well-received TV-movie,
Barbarians at the Gate, and went on to reprise his role as Jim Rockford in eight
The Rockford Files made-for-TV movies, beginning the following year. The frenetic opening theme song from the original series was rerecorded and slowed to a mournfully funereal pace, and practically everyone in the original cast of recurring characters returned for the new episodes except Beery, who had died in the interim.
In 1991, Garner starred in
Man of the People, a television series about a con man chosen to fill an empty seat on a city council, with
Kate Mulgrew and
Corinne Bohrer. Despite reasonably fair ratings, the show was canceled after only 10 episodes. Garner played
Wyatt Earp in two very different movies shot 21 years apart,
Hour of the Gun in 1967 and
Sunset in 1988. The first film was a realistic depiction of the
OK Corral shootout and its aftermath, while the second centered around a fictional relationship between Earp and silent movie cowboy star
Tom Mix. The film featured
Bruce Willis as Mix in only his second movie role. Although Willis was billed over Garner, the film actually gave more screen time and more emphasis to Earp.
Malcolm McDowell played a villainous silent comedian.
In 1994, Garner played an extremely Earp-like role as Marshal Zane Cooper in a movie version of
Maverick, with
Mel Gibson as Bret Maverick (in the end it is revealed that Garner's character is the father of Gibson's Maverick) and
Jodie Foster as a gambling lass with a fake southern accent. In 1995, he played lead character Woodrow Call, an ex-lawman, in the TV miseries sequel to
Lonesome Dove,
Streets of Laredo, based on
Larry McMurtry's book. The original Lonesome Dove story had been written as a movie script for a 1960s film to be directed by
Peter Bogdanovich and starring
John Wayne,
James Stewart, and
Henry Fonda, but Wayne turned the part down on
John Ford's advice and Stewart backed out as a result, so the movie was abandoned and McMurtry later turned the script into a full-scale novel,
Lonesome Dove, which eventually became a revered television miniseries with
Tommy Lee Jones in the Wayne role,
Robert Duvall in the Stewart part, and
Robert Urich filling in for Fonda as the cowboy regretfully hanged by his own friends. Garner had been offered
Robert Duvall's role in the original miniseries but had to turn it down for health reasons, and eventually wound up playing the part first portrayed by
Tommy Lee Jones and originally created for
John Wayne instead.
In 1996, Garner and
Jack Lemmon teamed up in
My Fellow Americans, playing two former presidents, both framed for scandalous activity in their days in the White House. In addition to a major recurring role during the last part of the run of TV series
Chicago Hope, Garner also starred in a couple of short-lived series, the animated
God, the Devil and Bob and
First Monday, in which he played a Supreme Court justice.
In 2000, after an operation to replace both knees, Garner appeared with
Clint Eastwood (who had played a villain in the original
Maverick series) in the movie
Space Cowboys, also featuring
Tommy Lee Jones and
Donald Sutherland. During a mass appearance by the cast on television's
The Tonight Show with Jay Leno, Leno ran a brief clip from Garner and Eastwood's lengthy saloon fistfight during Eastwood's
Maverick appearance over forty years earlier. In 2002, following the death of
James Coburn, Garner took over Coburn's responsibilities as TV commercial voiceover for Chevrolet's "Like a Rock" advertising campaign. Garner continued to voice the commercials until the end of the campaign. Upon the death of
John Ritter in 2003, Garner joined the cast of
8 Simple Rules as Grandpa Egan (Cate's father). Originally intended to be a one-shot guest role, he stayed with the series until its end.
In 2004, Garner starred in the movie version of
Nicholas Spark's The Notebook alongside
Gena Rowlands as his wife (played in flashbacks by
Rachel McAdams), directed by
Nick Cassavetes, Rowlands' son.