Henry's reign came to be marked by civil strife as the English barons, led by
Simon de Montfort, demanded more say in the running of the kingdom. French-born de Montfort had originally been one of the foreign upstarts so loathed by many as Henry's foreign councillors; after he married Henry’s sister Eleanor, without consulting Henry, a feud developed between the two. Their relationship reached a crisis in the 1250s when de Montfort was brought up on spurious charges for actions he took as lieutenant of
Gascony, the last remaining Plantagenet land across the
English Channel. He was acquitted by the
Peers of the realm, much to the King's displeasure.
Henry also became embroiled in funding a war in
Sicily on behalf of the
Pope in return for a title for his second son
Edmund, a state of affairs that made many barons fearful that Henry was following in the footsteps of his father,
King John, and needed to be kept in check, too. De Montfort became leader of those who wanted to reassert
Magna Carta and force the king to surrender more power to the baronial council. In 1258, seven leading barons forced Henry to agree to the
Provisions of Oxford, which effectively abolished the absolutist
Anglo-Norman monarchy, giving power to a council of fifteen barons to deal with the business of government and providing for a thrice-yearly meeting of
parliament to monitor their performance. Henry was forced to take part in the swearing of a collective oath to the
Provisions of Oxford.
In the following years, those supporting de Montfort and those supporting the king grew more and more polarised. Henry obtained a papal bull in 1262 exempting him from his oath and both sides began to raise armies. The Royalists were led by
Prince Edward, Henry's eldest son. Civil war, known as the
Second Barons' War, followed.
The charismatic de Montfort and his forces had captured most of southeastern England by 1263, and at the
Battle of Lewes on
14 May 1264, Henry was defeated and taken prisoner by de Montfort's army. While Henry was reduced to being a figurehead king, de Montfort broadened representation to include each county of England and many important towns—that is, to groups beyond the nobility. Henry and Edward continued under house arrest. The short period that followed was the closest England was to come to complete abolition of the
monarchy until the
Commonwealth period of 1649–1660 and many of the barons who had initially supported de Montfort began to suspect that he had gone too far with his reforming zeal.
But only fifteen months later Prince Edward had escaped captivity (having been freed by his cousin Roger Mortimer) to lead the royalists into battle again and he turned the tables on de Montfort at the
Battle of Evesham in 1265. Following this victory savage retribution was exacted on the rebels.