Due to the unsuccessful nature of the Yankees 2005 and 2006 postseasons and Rodriguez's sub .200 batting average in both of the series, Rodriguez has drawn much criticism in the New York area. Because of the Yankees' successful history, he is often compared unfavorably to other Yankees greats who have performed exceptionally well in the postseason, such as
Reggie Jackson.
While Rodriguez won the AL MVP award in 2005 and played a pivotal role in the Yankees defeat of the
Minnesota Twins in the 2004
ALDS, his recent postseason struggles have left fans frustrated. Rodriguez performed well in the earlier half of the 2004 postseason, hitting .320 with 3 home runs and 5 doubles in 50 at bats, but as was the case with the team in general, he ceased to pose an offensive threat during the final four games of the
ALCS against the
Boston Red Sox. The following postseason, Rodriguez went 2-for-15 in five games, and most recently, in the 2006 postseason, went 1-for-14 against the
Detroit Tigers. Through 2006, Rodriguez was a paltry 4-for-41 (.098 batting average) with no RBI in his last 12 postseason games.
Much of the criticism regarding Rodriguez is focused upon his alleged inability to produce hits in
clutch situations. However, during the 2003-05 regular seasons, Rodriguez posted a .371 batting average with the bases loaded and maintained an on base percentage of .422. In 2006, his numbers improved to .474 and .500 respectively. In 2007, through July 14 he hit .444 and .455, respectively. Additionally, Rodriguez's other batting lines during this period included a .432 average with a runner on third (.333 in 2006), .381 with a runner in scoring position (.302 in 2006), and .392 with a runner in scoring position and 2 outs (.313 in 2006; .333 in 2007 through July 14th).
In May 2006, Rodriguez responded to the criticism directed at him, saying:
"I could care less. In my career, I've been hearing it for a long time. It will never stop until you win five or six World Series in a row, and hit a Joe Carter home run. I've done a lot of special things in this game, and for none of that to be considered clutch, it's an injustice. I don't take anything personally; I enjoy it, it motivates me and I think it's comical. I think [for] anyone that drives in over 130 runs numerous times in his career, it's impossible not to be clutch."<ref><bgref>Mark Feinsand. <a rel
In an issue of
Sports Illustrated, Rodriguez surmised further reasons why he has become an apparent magnet for criticism, saying:
"When people write [bad things] about me, I don't know if it's [because] I'm good-looking, I'm biracial, I make the most money, I play on the most popular team."<ref name
Nonetheless, sportswriters, fans, and teammates have continued to debate Alex Rodriguez's performance in the clutch. Some writers such as the
New York Post's Joel Sherman have asked, "How do you disregard your eyes completely? How do you ignore that at the most intense moments Rodriguez seems to be carrying his 32-ounce bat and the weight of the world into each at-bat?" In the same issue of
Sports Illustrated cited earlier, teammate
Jason Giambi also criticized Rodriguez, remarking:"...you've got to get the big hit." However, Rodriguez and Giambi implied that the story was taken out of context, with Giambi claiming that his comments were part of a "pep talk", and not an argument, because he "was just trying to find a way to help him out." Rodriguez agreed, "This is the most support I've ever gotten from any team. I couldn't be more proud."
In the 2004 American League Championship Series, Rodriguez hit the ball out of
Boston Red Sox pitcher
Bronson Arroyo's hand while he was attempting to apply a tag. Rodriguez was subsequently called out by the umpires. Red Sox pitcher
Curt Schilling criticized Rodriguez by referring to the move as an example of “junior high school baseball."
Rodriguez also received considerable bad press when on
May 30, 2007, he yelled something (he says he yelled "Hah!"; the Blue Jays contend he yelled "Mine!") while rounding the bases in the ninth inning, distracting third baseman
Howie Clark of the
Toronto Blue Jays from making a play on a
fly ball in the infield. Many Jays players and sports personalities considered this poor sportsmanship and against the "unwritten" rules of baseball. Even Yankees manager Joe Torre considered this probably out of line, saying "It was probably inappropriate to do it at the time he did it, but you can't change it, unfortunately."
On
July 29, 2007, former baseball outfielder and steroid-user
Jose Canseco said that he was planning to publish another book about steroids in Major League Baseball, after his
2005 book
Juiced. Canseco said the book has "stuff" on Rodriguez, concerning steroids. Canseco did not come out and say anything specific about steroids making people theorize about what "stuff" Canseco has to say about Rodriguez.