Early and mid-1970s chart success
Mitchell moved to
California in late 1967. Her third album,
Ladies of the Canyon (1970), is infused with the spirit of the early seventies in Southern California when Joni and Graham Nash lived together in Laurel Canyon in the Hollywood Hills. Nash memorialized the period in the Crosby, Stills, and Nash song "Our House" (Our house is a very very very fine house, With two cats in the yard, Life used to be so hard, Now everything is easy cuz of you). Of immediate note on Ladies of the Canyon is Joni's unusual, heartfelt piano playing, used on about half the songs, while her acoustic guitar still dominates the rest. Also evident is the participation by other musicians, at least to a minor degree, the clarinet on "For Free," the flute and sax elsewhere. The title track, "Ladies of the Canyon," may be the most memorable song, but "Morning Morgantown," is an upbeat effort that seems to indicate how happy she was at that point in her life. Included is her first mainstream hit, "
Big Yellow Taxi", "The Arrangement," expressing the determination of 'the other woman' to free a married man from the shackles of what she thinks is an unhappy union, and the so-called 'anthem for a generation,' "
Woodstock", made popular by
Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young. Mitchell wrote the song after missing the
Woodstock music festival. She'd cancelled her intended appearance there on the advice of her manager for fear that she'd miss a scheduled appearance on
The Dick Cavett Show and has since called that career move one of the biggest regrets of her life. The album concludes with a poignant track, "The Circle Game," which like "Where Are You Going? (the Kodak commercial) or "Sunrise, Sunset" (from "Fiddler on the Roof") considers the cycles of our lives from birth until death.
Mitchell again alternated use of acoustic guitar and piano on
Blue (1971), which some consider the best of her first five albums. A more accurate appraisal might characterize it as a culmination of her inspired early work, with depressed assessments of the world around her serving as counterpoint to exuberant expressions of romantic love. Mitchell later remarked, "At that period of my life, I had no personal defenses. I felt like a cellophane wrapper on a pack of cigarettes. I felt like I had absolutely no secrets from the world and I couldn't pretend in my life to be strong." The album featured increasing use of
Appalachian dulcimer on "
Carey" , "California", "All I Want", and the beautifully sung "
A Case of You. "Little Green" is a touching lament about having to give up her daughter for adoption when Joni was under twenty, prior to leaving Canada and heading south to America, as did the child's father before her (Born with the moon in Cancer, Choose her a name she will answer to, Call her green and the winters cannot fade her, Call her green for the children who have made her, Little green, be a gypsy dancer). Mother and daughter were reunited in the nineties and Joni explained in an interview with NPR in October of 2004 that with the renewed relationship, she no longer felt the need or even the urge to make music.
"
River" found Joni in warmer climes at Christmastime, probably L.A., where she may have found the commercialized celebration somehow disappointing and her way of life, in general, a "crazy scene." Her thoughts, perhaps, turned to her formative years back home ("I wish I had a river / I could skate away on"). The song has been covered by numerous artists, including
Aimee Mann,
Indigo Girls,
Robert Downey Jr.,
Allison Crowe,
Sarah McLachlan,
Michael Ball,
Dianne Reeves,
Rachael Yamagata,
James Taylor, and a duet by
Madeleine Peyroux and
k.d. lang.
Other songs of note on the album are "My Old Man" (We don't need no piece of paper From the city hall, Keeping us tied and true, No, my old man, Keeping away my lonesome blues), and "The Last Time I Saw Richard," a cynical but ultimately hopeful assessment of what happens to sentimental romantics in this dog eat dog world (I'm gonna blow this damn candle out, I don't want nobody comin' over to my table, I got nothing to talk to anybody about, All good dreamers pass this way someday, Hidin' behind bottles in dark cafes, dark cafes, Only a dark cacoon before I get my gorgeous wings and fly away, Only a phase, these dark cafe days.)
Joni's next album was
For the Roses (1972), which included the country-influenced hit single "You Turn Me On, I'm a Radio." From an artistic standpoint, however, For the Roses is certainly one of her best early efforts, heralding the emerging transition in her music to more complex and interesting arrangements. She seemed to be reaching for a fuller, more collaborative sound by giving other accomplished musicians a greater role as backup while reflecting upon her life and personality in a somewhat clearer and more mature fashion. Tracks of particular note are the lilting "Cold Blue Steel and Sweet Fire," the poignant "Lesson in Survival," which expressed her longing for greater privacy (I need more quiet times, By a river flowing, You and me, Deep kisses and the sun going down), her sense of isolation (Your friends protect you, Scrutinize me, I get so damn timid, Not at all the spirit that's inside of me, Oh baby I can't seem to make it with you socially, There's this reef around me), and her love for nature (I'm looking way out at the ocean, Love to see that green water in motion). Also included in the collection is the moving and poetic "Let the Wind Carry Me," in which Joni contrasts thoughts of a more stable, conventional life with her overpowering need to live with minimal constraints upon her freedom (I get that strong longing and I wanna settle down and raise a child up with somebody, But it passes like the summer, I'm a wild seed again, Let the wind carry me). "Electricity," a lovely melody with interesting and wonderfully unpretentious lyrics, is reminiscent of "Sisotowbell Lane" from Song to a Seagull in that it extolls the simplicity and serenity of the quiet country life (Well, I'm learning, It's peaceful, With a good dog and some trees, Out of touch with the breakdown Of this century, They're not going to fix it up Too easy) while the impressive and beautifully sung "Woman of Heart and Mind," in which she gently chides her lover, may be the album's centerpiece. It concludes with "Judgement of the Moon and the Stars," a powerful call to action by individuals rather than pressure groups (You've got to shake your fist at lightning now, You've got to roar like a forest fire, You've got to spread your light like blazes, All across the sky, They're going to aim the hoses on you, Show 'em you won't expire, Not 'til you burn up every passion, Not even when you die). All in all, For the Roses is a significant artistic achievment and edges up on a tour de force, which sadly has been overlooked and underrated by many of those who attempt to review Joni Mitchell's long and distinguished career from a commercial standpoint, only, because that's all they really understand. Included on the green cover is a photo of her sitting on the verdant bank of a river wearing boots and a green velour outfit, while inside the back of the jacket is a naked photo where she is standing on the beach, looking out to sea. While "defenders of the faith" thought this ill-advised and a tad scandalous, it was in keeping with the naturalistic, earth-loving sentiments of the era and the values of a younger, counterculture crowd who formed the bulk of her fan base. They loved it.
Mitchell's next album,
Court and Spark (1974), was her most commercially successful, critically acclaimed, and widely popular collection of songs. A new set of mainstream fans who up to that point had not been much impressed with her music or who'd never even heard of her began singing her praises and calling her their own. This unexpected phenomenon had the effect of alienating the core of her fan base, that is, the more introspective and sensitive people who'd found refuge in her early work and been among her most ardent admirers. Many of them scorned the album and felt somehow betrayed, despite the general acclaim that attended its release, and some even charged that Joni had sold out in order to achieve "success," allowing her personal and professional life to be appropriated by a cadre of hangers-on looking to feather their own nests at her expense. However, in retrospect, that view may present a distorted picture. The increasing production on her albums, if not the widespread commercial appeal, certainly did not happen overnight, but these questions aside, Court and Spark contained such popular tracks as "
Free Man in Paris" and "
Help Me," and is often said to include the first jazz elements in Mitchell's work. She spent the rest of the decade creating more free-form, jazz-inflected music.