Last years and masterworks
In 1823 appeared Schubert's first
song cycle, Die schöne Müllerin (D.795), after poems by
Wilhelm Müller. This work, together with the later cycle "
Winterreise" (D.911; also written to texts of Müller) is widely considered one of the pinnacles of
Lieder. The song
Du bist die Ruh ("You are stillness/peace") D.776 was also composed during this year.
In the spring of 1824 he wrote the
Octet in F (D.803), "A Sketch for a Grand Symphony"; and in the summer went back to
Želiezovce, when he became attracted by
Hungarian idiom, and wrote the
Divertissement a l'Hongroise (D.818) and the
String Quartet in A minor (D.804). It has been said that he held a hopeless passion for his pupil Countess Karoline Eszterházy; if this is the case, the details are unknown to historians.
Despite his preoccupation with the stage and later with his official duties, he found time during these years for a good deal of miscellaneous composition. The
Mass in A flat (D.678) was completed and the "Unfinished Symphony" (
Symphony No. 8 in B minor, D.759) begun in 1822. The question of why the symphony was "unfinished" has been debated endlessly and is still unresolved. To 1824, beside the works mentioned above, belong the variations for flute and piano on
Trockne Blumen, from the cycle
Die schöne Müllerin. There is also a
sonata for piano and arpeggione (D.821). This music is nowadays usually played by either
cello or
viola and piano, although a number of other arrangements have been made.
The mishaps of the recent years were compensated by the prosperity and happiness of 1825. Publication had been moving more rapidly; the stress of poverty was for a time lightened; in the summer there was a pleasant holiday in Upper Austria, where Schubert was welcomed with enthusiasm. It was during this tour that he produced his "
Songs from Sir Walter Scott". This cycle contains his famous and beloved
Ellens dritter Gesang (D.839). This is today more popularly, though mistakenly, referred to as "Schubert's
Ave Maria"; while he had set it to
Adam Storck's German translation of
Scott's hymn from
The Lady of the Lake that happens to open with the greeting
Ave Maria and also has it for its refrain, subsequently the entire Scott/Storck text in Schubert's song came to be substituted with the complete Latin text of the traditional
Ave Maria prayer; and it is in this adaptation that this song of Schubert's is commonly sung today. During this time he also wrote the
Piano Sonata in A minor (D.845, Op. 42) and the
Symphony No. 9 (D.944), which is believed to have been completed the following year, in 1826.
From 1826 to 1828 Schubert resided continuously in Vienna, except for a brief visit to
Graz in
1827. The history of his life during these three years is little more than a record of his compositions. The only events worth notice are that in 1826 he dedicated a symphony to the
Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde and received an honorarium in return. In the spring of 1828 he gave, for the first and only time in his career, a public concert of his own works which was very well received. But the compositions themselves are a sufficient biography. The
String Quartet in D minor (D.810), with the variations on
Death and the Maiden, was written during the winter of 1825-1826, and first played on
January 25, 1826. Later in the year came the String Quartet in G major, the "Rondeau brilliant" for piano and violin (D.895, Op.70), and the Piano Sonata in G (D.894, Op.78) (first published under the title "Fantasia in G"). To these should be added the three Shakespearian songs, of which "
Hark! Hark! the Lark" (D.889) and "
Who is Sylvia?" (D.891) were allegedly written on the same day, the former at a tavern where he broke his afternoon's walk, the latter on his return to his lodging in the evening.
In 1827 Schubert wrote the song cycle
Winterreise (D.911), a colossal peak of the art of art-song, the
Fantasia for piano and violin in C (D.934), and the two piano trios (B flat, D.898; and E flat, D.929): in 1828 the
Song of Miriam, the Mass in E-flat (D.950), the
Tantum Ergo (D.962) in the same key, the
String Quintet in C (D.956), the second Benedictus to the Mass in C, the last three piano sonatas, and the collection of songs published posthumously under the fanciful name of
Schwanengesang ("Swan-song", D.957), which whilst not a true song cycle, retains a unity of style amongst the individual songs, touching unwonted depths of tragedy and the morbidly supernatural. Six of these are to words by
Heinrich Heine, whose
Buch der Lieder appeared in the autumn. The
Symphony No. 9 (D.944) is dated 1828, and many modern Schubert scholars (including
Brian Newbould) believe that this symphony, written in 1825-6, was revised for performance in 1828 (a fairly unusual practice for Schubert, for whom publication, let alone performance, was rarely contemplated for many of his larger-scale works during his lifetime). In the last weeks of his life he began to sketch three movements for a new Symphony in D (D.936A).
The works of his last two years reveal a composer increasingly meditating on the darker side of the human psyche and human relationships, and with a deeper sense of spiritual awareness and conception of the 'beyond', reaching extraordinary depths in several chillingly dark songs of this period, especially in the larger cycles, (the song
Der Doppelgaenger reaching an extraordinary climax, conveying madness at the realization of rejection and imminent death, and yet able to touch repose and communion with the infinite in the almost timeless ebb and flow of the String Quintet). Schubert expressed the wish, were he to survive his final illness, to further develop his knowledge of harmony and counterpoint.