1860–1861: The nation disintegrates
When Republicans won a plurality in the House in
1858, every significant bill they passed fell before southern votes in the Senate or a Presidential
veto. The Federal Government reached a stalemate. Bitter hostility between Republicans and Southern members prevailed on the floor of Congress.
To make matters worse, Buchanan was dogged by the partisan
Covode committee, which was investigating the administration for evidence of impeachable offenses.
Sectional strife rose to such a pitch in 1860 that the Democratic Party split. Buchanan played little part as the national convention meeting in Charleston deadlocked. The southern wing walked out of the Charleston convention and nominated its own candidate for the presidency, incumbent Vice President
John C. Breckinridge, whom Buchanan refused to support. The remainder of the party finally nominated Buchanan's archenemy, Douglas. Consequently, when the Republicans nominated
Abraham Lincoln, it was a foregone conclusion that he would be elected even though his name appeared on no southern ballot. Buchanan watched silently as South Carolina seceded on December 20, followed by six other
cotton states, and by February, they formed the
Confederate States of America. Eight slave states refused to join.
In Buchanan's Message to Congress (
December 3, 1860), he denied the legal right of states to secede but held that the Federal Government legally could not prevent them. He hoped for compromise, but secessionist leaders did not want it.
Beginning in late December, Buchanan reorganized his cabinet, ousting Confederate sympathizers and replacing them with hard-line nationalists
Jeremiah S. Black, Edwin M. Stanton, Joseph Holt and
John A. Dix. These conservative Democrats strongly believed in American nationalism and refused to countenance secession. At one point, Treasury Secretary Dix ordered Treasury agents in New Orleans, "If any man pulls down the American flag, shoot him on the spot".
Before Buchanan left office, seven
slave states seceded, the Confederacy was formed, all arsenals and forts in the seceded states were lost (except
Fort Sumter and two remote ones), and a fourth of all federal soldiers surrendered to
Texas troops. The government decided to hold on to Fort Sumter, which was located in
Charleston harbor, the most visible spot in the Confederacy. On
January 5, Buchanan sent a civilian steamer
Star of the West to carry reinforcements and supplies to
Fort Sumter. On
January 9, 1861, South Carolina state batteries opened fire on the
Star of the West, which returned to
New York. Paralyzed, Buchanan made no further moves to prepare for war.
Historians in 2006 voted his failure to deal with secession the worst presidential mistake ever made.
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20060218/presidential_errors_060218/20060218?hub=World
On Buchanan's final day as president, he remarked to the incoming
Abraham Lincoln, "If you are as happy in entering the White House as I shall feel on returning to Wheatland you are a happy man."
James Buchanan's
average historical ranking by scholars considering presidential achievements, leadership qualities, failures and faults (such as corruption), is a lowly 36.58 (with smaller numbers reflecting better scores), placing him 41st out of a total of 42 presidents.