Hitchcock's
gallows humour and the suspense that became his trademark continued in his American work. However, working arrangements with his new producer were less than optimal. Selznick suffered from perennial money problems and Hitchcock was often unhappy with the amount of creative control demanded by Selznick over his films. Consequently, Selznick ended up "loaning" Hitchcock to the larger studios more often than producing Hitchcock's films himself. In addition, Selznick, as well as fellow independent producer
Samuel Goldwyn, made only a few films each year, so Selznick did not always have projects for Hitchcock to direct. Remarkably, Goldwyn had also negotiated with Hitchcock on a possible contract, only to be outbid by Selznick. Hitchcock was quickly impressed with the superior resources of the American studios compared to the financial restrictions he had frequently encountered in England. Nevertheless, Hitchcock's fondness for his homeland resulted in numerous American films set in, or filmed in, the United Kingdom, right up to his next-to-last film,
Frenzy.
With the prestigious Selznick picture
Rebecca in 1940, Hitchcock made his first American movie, although it was set in England and based on a novel by English author
Daphne du Maurier and starred
Sir Laurence Olivier and
Joan Fontaine. This
Gothic melodrama explores the fears of a naïve young bride who enters a great English country home and must grapple with the problems of a distant husband, a predatory housekeeper, and the legacy of her husband's late wife, the beautiful, mysterious Rebecca. It won the
Academy Award for
Best Picture of 1940. However, the statuette went to Selznick as the film's producer, and the film did not win the
Best Director award. There were additional problems between Selznick and Hitchcock; Selznick, as he usually did, imposed very restrictive rules upon Hitchcock, hindering his creative control. Hitchcock was forced to shoot the film as Selznick wanted, immediately creating friction within their relationship. At the same time, Selznick complained about Hitchcock's "goddam jigsaw cutting," which meant that the producer did not have nearly the leeway to create his own film as he liked, but had to follow Hitchcock's vision of the finished product. The film was the third longest of Hitchcock's films at 130 minutes, exceeded only by
The Paradine Case at 132 minutes and
North by Northwest at 136 minutes.
Hitchcock's second American film, the European-set thriller
Foreign Correspondent (originally titled
Personal History), was also nominated for Best Picture that year. It was filmed in the first year of
World War II and inspired by the rapidly-changing events in Europe, as covered by an American newspaper reporter portrayed by a wise-cracking
Joel McCrea. The film cleverly used actual footage of European scenes and scenes filmed on a Hollywood backlot. Curiously, because of Hollywood's Production Code censorship, the film avoided direct references to Germany and Germans.
Hitchcock's work during the 1940s was diverse, ranging from the romantic comedy
Mr. & Mrs. Smith (1941) and the courtroom drama
The Paradine Case (1947) to the dark and disturbing
Shadow of a Doubt (1943).
Suspicion (1941) marked Hitchcock's first film as a producer as well as director. This was Cary Grant's first film with Hitchcock. Joan Fontaine won Best Actress Oscar and New York Film Critics Circle Award for her outstanding performance in
Suspicion.
Saboteur (1942) was the first of two films that Hitchcock made for
Universal, a studio where he would work in his later years. Hitchcock was forced to utilize Universal contract players
Robert Cummings and
Priscilla Lane, both known for their work in comedies and light dramas; Hitchcock made the most of the situation and got remarkably good performances from the two lead actors. Breaking with Hollywood conventions of the time, Hitchcock did extensive location filming, especially in
New York City, and memorably depicted a confrontation between a suspected saboteur (Cummings) and a real saboteur (
Norman Lloyd) atop the
Statue of Liberty.
Shadow of a Doubt (1943), his personal favourite of all his films and the second of the early Universal films, was about young Charlotte "Charlie" Newton (
Teresa Wright), who suspects her beloved uncle Charlie Oakley (
Joseph Cotten) of being a serial murderer. In its use of overlapping characters, dialogue, and closeups it has provided a generation of film theorists with psychoanalytic potential, including
Jacques Lacan and
Slavoj Žižek. The film also harkens back to one of Cotten's best known films,
Citizen Kane. Hitchcock again filmed extensively on location, this time in the Northern California city of
Santa Rosa, during the summer of 1942. The director showcased his own personal fascination with crime and criminals when he had two of his characters discuss various ways of killing people, to the obvious annoyance of Charlotte.
Working at
20th Century Fox, Hitchcock adapted a script by
John Steinbeck that dealt with the survivors of a German U-boat attack,
Lifeboat (1944). Since the action was confined to the small boat, the film was clearly the most confined of Hitchcock's films. While at Fox, Hitchcock seriously considered directing the film version of
A.J. Cronin's novel about a Catholic priest in China,
The Keys of the Kingdom, but the plans for this fell through.
John M. Stahl ended up directing the 1944 film, which was produced by
Joseph L. Mankiewicz and starred
Gregory Peck, among other luminaries.
Returning to England for an extended visit in late 1943 and early 1944, Hitchcock filmed two short films for the Ministry of Information,
Bon Voyage and
Aventure Malgache. The films were made for France's free territories and were the only ones Hitchcock made in French; they feature typical Hitchcockian touches. In the 1990s, the two films were shown by
Turner Classic Movies and released on home video.
In 1945, Hitchcock served as "treatment advisor" (in effect, editor) for a Holocaust documentary produced by the British Army. The film, which recorded the liberation of
Concentration Camps, remained unreleased until 1985, when it was completed by
PBS Frontline and distributed under the title
Memory of the Camps.
Hitchcock worked again for Selznick when he directed
Spellbound, which explored the then-fashionable subject of
psychoanalysis and featured a dream sequence designed by
Salvador Dalí. The dream sequence as it actually appears in the film is considerably shorter than was originally envisioned, which was to be several minutes long, because it proved to be too disturbing for the audience. Some of the memorable and original musical score by
Miklos Rozsa was later adapted by the composer into a concert piano concerto.
Notorious (1946) followed
Spellbound. As Selznick failed to see its potential, he allowed Hitchcock to make the film for
RKO. From this point onwards, Hitchcock would produce his own films, giving him a far greater degree of freedom to pursue the projects that interested him.
Notorious starred Hitchcock regulars
Ingrid Bergman and
Cary Grant and features a plot about Nazis, uranium, and South America. It was a huge box office success and has remained one of Hitchcock's most acclaimed films. His use of
uranium as a plot device briefly led to Hitchcock's being under surveillance by the FBI. McGilligan wrote that Hitchcock consulted scientists about the development of an atomic bomb; Selznick complained that the notion was "science fiction," only to be confronted by the detonation of two atomic bombs in 1945 that led to the end of World War II.
After completing his final film for Selznick,
The Paradine Case (a promising courtroom drama that critics found lost momentum because it apparently ran too long and exhausted its resource of ideas), Hitchcock filmed his first colour film,
Rope, which appeared in 1948. Here Hitchcock experimented with marshalling suspense in a confined environment, as he had done earlier with
Lifeboat (1943). He also experimented with exceptionally long takes — up to ten minutes long (see
Themes and devices). Featuring
James Stewart in the leading role,
Rope was the first of four films Stewart would make for Hitchcock. It was based on the
Leopold and Loeb case of the 1920s. Somehow Hitchcock's cameraman managed to move the bulky, heavy
Technicolor camera quickly around the set as it followed the continuous action of the long takes.
Under Capricorn (1949), set in nineteenth-century Australia, also used the short-lived technique of long takes, but to a more limited extent. He again used
Technicolor in this production, then returned to black and white films for several years. For
Rope and
Under Capricorn Hitchcock formed a production company with Sidney Bernstein, called
Transatlantic Pictures, which became inactive after these two unsuccessful pictures. Hitchcock continued to produce his films for the rest of his life.